1 | <!doctype html public "-//w3c//dtd html 4.0 transitional//en">
|
---|
2 | <html>
|
---|
3 | <head>
|
---|
4 | <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">
|
---|
5 | <meta name="Author" content="Marilee Mongello">
|
---|
6 | <meta name="GENERATOR" content="Mozilla/4.61 [en] (Win98; I) [Netscape]">
|
---|
7 | <title>Tudor Citizens - Thomas Cromwell</title>
|
---|
8 | </head>
|
---|
9 | <body text="#000000" bgcolor="#FFFFFF" link="#006600" vlink="#006600" alink="#000000">
|
---|
10 |
|
---|
11 | <center><img SRC="cromwell.gif" ALT="Thomas Cromwell" height=59 width=313>
|
---|
12 | <br>born c.1485 in Putney
|
---|
13 | <br>executed 28 July 1540 in London
|
---|
14 | <p><b><font size=+1>"A good household manager, but not fit to meddle in
|
---|
15 | the affairs of kings."</font></b>
|
---|
16 | <br><font size=-1>May 1538, Henry VIII describes Cromwell to the French
|
---|
17 | ambassador</font></center>
|
---|
18 |
|
---|
19 | <p><img SRC="cromwell-small.jpg" ALT="portrait of Cromwell as the earl of Essex" BORDER=2 height=264 width=220 align=LEFT>
|
---|
20 | Thomas Cromwell was as great a statesman as England has ever seen and,
|
---|
21 | in his decade of power, permanently changed the course of English history.
|
---|
22 | Unlike his mentor, Cardinal Wolsey, Cromwell was not a priest or a papist.
|
---|
23 | He was a lawyer determined to impose his own character - methodical, detached,
|
---|
24 | and calculating - upon government.
|
---|
25 | <p> Cromwell wanted government to be effective and efficient;
|
---|
26 | to achieve this, he had to end the chaos of feudal privilege and ill-defined
|
---|
27 | jurisdictions. He was blessed with a logical mind in an age sadly
|
---|
28 | devoid of them. And unlike his royal master, he did not let his emotions
|
---|
29 | interfere with his position. He was the ideal statesman for Tudor
|
---|
30 | England and, just months after his execution in 1540, Henry VIII was bemoaning
|
---|
31 | his loss.
|
---|
32 | <p> Cromwell was introduced to government service as
|
---|
33 | a secretary for <a href="wolsey.html">Cardinal
|
---|
34 | Wolsey</a>. His abilities won him the older man's respect and soon
|
---|
35 | Cromwell was his most trusted servant and principal secretary. But
|
---|
36 | Cromwell managed to distance himself from Wolsey immediately after the
|
---|
37 | Cardinal fell from grace and soon had taken his place as Henry's most valuable
|
---|
38 | advisor. Before entering Wolsey's service, Cromwell lived an adventurous
|
---|
39 | life. His father had been a brewer and blacksmith known for permanent
|
---|
40 | drunkenness and illegal activities. From this inauspicious beginning,
|
---|
41 | his son went on to indulge his curiosity and practical nature by traveling
|
---|
42 | through Europe. Over the course of several years, he was a soldier
|
---|
43 | in Europe, a banker in Italy, clerk in the Netherlands, and a lawyer in
|
---|
44 | London. Like so many ambitious men, he was in Wolsey's service in
|
---|
45 | the mid-1520s. His most important work was the suppression of 29
|
---|
46 | religious houses whose monies Wolsey used to endow colleges at Ipswich
|
---|
47 | and Oxford. When Wolsey fell from grace in 1529, Cromwell was hurriedly
|
---|
48 | elected burgess for Taunton so he could remain in government service.
|
---|
49 | <p> There were striking similarities between the two
|
---|
50 | men - both managed to remain favorites of the mercurial Henry VIII for
|
---|
51 | years; both were despised by the older nobility who coveted their influence
|
---|
52 | with the king; both sought to reform the creaky medieval bureaucracy of
|
---|
53 | Tudor government; both were highly intelligent and well-versed in international
|
---|
54 | affairs. And both, ultimately, fell from Henry's favor with spectacular
|
---|
55 | speed. In the end, the king preferred to listen to the old nobility.
|
---|
56 | <p> But Cromwell and Wolsey were also markedly different
|
---|
57 | in many ways. Cromwell was the man responsible for the Henrician
|
---|
58 | reformation while Wolsey fell because he served two masters, the king of
|
---|
59 | England and the Pope. Though Henry had ejected Rome from his nation,
|
---|
60 | he still practiced the Roman Catholic religion. The king's religious
|
---|
61 | tendencies were never reformist and many historians have made the mistake
|
---|
62 | of painting him as one of the first Protestant kings. Henry was never
|
---|
63 | a Protestant and he wrote treatises vilifying Martin Luther for which he
|
---|
64 | was titled 'Defender of the Faith' by the Pope. Rather, he was an
|
---|
65 | opportunist who disliked papal authority and interference in his realm
|
---|
66 | and wanted some of the vast wealth the English church possessed.
|
---|
67 | For Henry, often desperately short of money, it was near-blasphemy for
|
---|
68 | his subjects to pay taxes directly to Rome; he wanted the money for his
|
---|
69 | government. He also wanted an annulment from a devoutly Catholic
|
---|
70 | wife, Katharine of Aragon, and when the Pope, held hostage by the Holy
|
---|
71 | Roman Emperor, refused to rule in his favor, he found it most expedient
|
---|
72 | to simply disregard the papacy. But throughout it all, Henry was
|
---|
73 | unaware of the forces he had unleashed when he declared himself head of
|
---|
74 | the English church. Trained for the church as a child, he remained
|
---|
75 | staunchly Catholic for his entire life though the Catholic church deemed
|
---|
76 | him a heretic.
|
---|
77 | <center>
|
---|
78 | <p><b><u><font color="#000000">a discussion of the Henrician reformation</font></u></b></center>
|
---|
79 |
|
---|
80 | <p> It is important to remember that during Henry's reign,
|
---|
81 | at least half of his subjects were under the age of eighteen. Henry's
|
---|
82 | court swarmed with young people - pages, scullery maids, and the like.
|
---|
83 | English culture celebrated youth; tournaments, hunts, glorious warfare
|
---|
84 | were all the province of the young and strong. And while Henry was
|
---|
85 | young, he joined these events with a gusto sadly lacking in his father
|
---|
86 | or son. But time does not stop, not even for a despotic monarch determined
|
---|
87 | to have his way in all things. During his 'great matter', Henry was
|
---|
88 | in his thirties and changing from 'Bluff King Hal' into an overweight and
|
---|
89 | balding hypochondriac. He had rid himself of Rome to gain wealth
|
---|
90 | and a son. He gained both and, once he had, continually toyed with
|
---|
91 | the idea of making peace with the pope. He didn't relish excommunication
|
---|
92 | and it is likely that he persuaded himself that he wasn't disobeying Christ's
|
---|
93 | vicar but rather the Emperor's puppet.
|
---|
94 | <p> But he misjudged the mood of his people, particularly
|
---|
95 | his nobles. Educated and by nature inquisitive and acquisitive, the
|
---|
96 | new Protestant teachings intrigued them; they also sought the vast monastic
|
---|
97 | lands which Henry planned to sell. This was the paradox of the Henrician
|
---|
98 | reformation. It was motivated by greed and genuine religious turmoil.
|
---|
99 | As time passed, the new generation of nobles were Protestant because it
|
---|
100 | was expedient and philosophically appealing. And with each year,
|
---|
101 | more Englishmen were born who were further and further away from the old
|
---|
102 | days of Roman domination. Henry, in his forties, could remember the
|
---|
103 | papist ways but, as the years passed, fewer and fewer of his subjects did.
|
---|
104 | <p> In terms of the practical effect the reformation
|
---|
105 | had on everyday Englishmen, the situation is more difficult to gauge.
|
---|
106 | Unlike the wealthy noblemen, they couldn't bid on the seized monastic properties.
|
---|
107 | And in many towns and villages, the parish church was the community center,
|
---|
108 | where births, weddings, and deaths were officiated over by a priest.
|
---|
109 | But they undoubtedly enjoyed not paying their tax to Rome. Once again,
|
---|
110 | a paradox emerged - an excommunicated nation which found itself torn between
|
---|
111 | loyalty to the sovereign and loyalty to the papacy. Also, since Henry's
|
---|
112 | marriage to Anne Boleyn could only be recognized if one accepted his annulment
|
---|
113 | from Katharine - which in itself meant a rejection of papal authority -
|
---|
114 | and it was treason to <i>not</i> recognize his marriage to Anne, then many
|
---|
115 | people were swayed by the threat of execution. In other words, accept
|
---|
116 | Henry's decisions or die. Of course, I cannot discuss all aspects
|
---|
117 | of the reformation at this site; I recommend L.B. Smith's <i>Henry VIII</i>
|
---|
118 | which studies Henry's own theological beliefs.
|
---|
119 | <p> There was opposition to the reformation which probably
|
---|
120 | had more to do with the attendant loss of independence in north England.
|
---|
121 | In 1536, a northern uprising which came to be called the Pilgrimage of
|
---|
122 | Grace, gathered over 40,000 men and marched through England. It eventually
|
---|
123 | destroyed itself by internal division and lack of clear purpose but one
|
---|
124 | of the rebels' demands was a warning for Cromwell - they want their king
|
---|
125 | to be advised by <i>noble</i> councilors who understand the people's wishes,
|
---|
126 | not common men like Cromwell. Henry was angry at their presumption
|
---|
127 | - how dare his ignorant subjects rebel annd then tell him how to run the
|
---|
128 | country! - but he was persuaded to show mercy and pardon those involved.
|
---|
129 | And he continued to listen to Cromwell.
|
---|
130 | <p> The <a href="../primary.html">Pilgrimage
|
---|
131 | of Grace</a> was largely motivated not by religious concerns but by Cromwell's
|
---|
132 | determination to dissolve the monasteries and improve the royal tax collecting
|
---|
133 | methods. For example, the movement began in Louth, in Lincolnshire,
|
---|
134 | and began with the murder of two tax collectors, one of whom was hanged
|
---|
135 | and the other sewn into a sack and thrown to a pack of hungry dogs!
|
---|
136 | <p> So the common people might grumble somewhat but they
|
---|
137 | were ultimately more influenced by practical matters. Had Henry's
|
---|
138 | excommunication been followed by a terrible harvest or bad weather, it
|
---|
139 | may have been otherwise. During his daughter Mary's reign, such signs
|
---|
140 | were taken to mean God was angry with her for attempting to reinstate Catholicism.
|
---|
141 | But not only did Henry enjoy good weather, he had a brilliant servant.
|
---|
142 | Cromwell was the one who gave force to Henry's grand declarations.
|
---|
143 | The king declared that Rome had no authority in England and Cromwell instituted
|
---|
144 | the reforms which would make it so. The king declared that all monastic
|
---|
145 | lands were forfeit and Cromwell set out to close the monasteries, assess
|
---|
146 | their value, and sell them to the highest bidder. For a decade, this
|
---|
147 | partnership worked marvelously.
|
---|
148 | <p> Also, Henry and Cromwell both recognized a fundamental
|
---|
149 | truth of the English people; the government could do what it liked as long
|
---|
150 | as traditional religious views were not upset too much. Certainly
|
---|
151 | Henry did not upset his own. The name of the pope was omitted in
|
---|
152 | their prayers but not much else. Henry's break with Rome was really
|
---|
153 | a legal reformation rather than one of real religious content. England
|
---|
154 | practiced Catholicism without a pope and, in his place, was their king.
|
---|
155 | This situation suited Cromwell. Like many, he recognized that the
|
---|
156 | Church had lost its way, remaining a ponderous medieval institution concerned
|
---|
157 | with wealth and influence. But Europe was no longer medieval; countries
|
---|
158 | were becoming nation-states, patriotic and immune to the cultural unity
|
---|
159 | which Rome promoted. The pope envisioned a collection of nations
|
---|
160 | joined beneath the cloak of Christendom with him at its head; but, particularly
|
---|
161 | in xenophobic England, there were mutterings that the church was dominated
|
---|
162 | by other nations. Also, the church claimed authority over its subjects;
|
---|
163 | no priest or cleric could be tried by their sovereign nation. They
|
---|
164 | would answer only to Rome. This problem had angered Henry II centuries
|
---|
165 | before and resulted in Thomas Becket's murder. In Henry's time, it
|
---|
166 | had grown worse. Also, as king, he believed himself ruler of <i>all</i>
|
---|
167 | his subjects, priest and commoner alike.
|
---|
168 | <p> One must also mention the corruption of the church,
|
---|
169 | sadly evident to everyone. Certainly there were Godly men who struggled
|
---|
170 | to enforce the tenets of their faith. But there were also bishops
|
---|
171 | and cardinals more interested in business and finance than theology.
|
---|
172 | The church preached that the surest path to heaven was through good works,
|
---|
173 | particularly at a monastery or abbey, but every Englishmen knew that only
|
---|
174 | the wealthy could afford to endow or board at them. Furthermore,
|
---|
175 | an increasing number of churchmen were absent from their posts. Cardinal
|
---|
176 | Wolsey embodied this avaricious streak; he was bishop, archbishop, abbot,
|
---|
177 | and cardinal yet the affairs of state kept him from his duties. Instead
|
---|
178 | of tending to his flock, he tended to his purse. He sired illegitimate
|
---|
179 | children and collected nearly 50,000 pds a year from his vast holdings.
|
---|
180 | <p> Wolsey represented the church as it had become; certainly
|
---|
181 | such abuses may not have turned most Englishmen from their faith.
|
---|
182 | But when confronted with the forces of Protestantism, the church found
|
---|
183 | precious few willing to die for their beliefs. After all, why would
|
---|
184 | anyone die for a faith they didn't respect? When the king styled
|
---|
185 | himself head of the church, many were perhaps relieved. Henry made
|
---|
186 | no claim to a holy life, not like the churchman Wolsey; he also was shrewd
|
---|
187 | enough to endow his monarchy with papal apparatus. From the 1530s
|
---|
188 | on, the Tudor dynasty was even more divine and the machinery of state could
|
---|
189 | enforce its divinity.
|
---|
190 | <center>
|
---|
191 | <p><b><u><font color="#000000">Cromwell's revolution in government</font></u></b></center>
|
---|
192 |
|
---|
193 | <p> Cromwell's rise to power was extraordinary and occurred
|
---|
194 | just when Henry needed a minister of great administrative imagination and
|
---|
195 | genius, uninterested in the squabbles of his council and determined to
|
---|
196 | empower the machinery of state. Cromwell entered royal service in
|
---|
197 | early 1530 and, from then on, rose rapidly. In late 1530 he was sworn
|
---|
198 | into the King's Council and, just a year later, began to attract unfavorable
|
---|
199 | attention from Wolsey's old rivals. These were Stephen Gardiner,
|
---|
200 | bishop of Winchester, Thomas Howard, duke of Norfolk, and Charles Brandon,
|
---|
201 | duke of Suffolk. Gardiner had worked with Wolsey but, like Norfolk
|
---|
202 | and Suffolk, viewed the Cardinal's fall as a chance to take his place.
|
---|
203 | From 1529 to about 1533, they enjoyed the king's confidence even as Cromwell
|
---|
204 | rose to overtake them all. His career progressed as follows:
|
---|
205 | <br><b><font color="#990000">1531</font></b> - member of the privy council
|
---|
206 | <br><b><font color="#990000">1532</font></b> - Master of Court of Wards
|
---|
207 | and Master of Jewel House
|
---|
208 | <br><b><font color="#990000">1533</font></b> - Chancellor of the Exchequer
|
---|
209 | <br><font color="#990000"><b>1534</b> </font>- King's Secretary and Master
|
---|
210 | of the Rolls
|
---|
211 | <br><b><font color="#990000">1535</font></b> - Vicar-General
|
---|
212 | <br><b><font color="#990000">1536</font></b> - Lord Privy Seal and Baron
|
---|
213 | Cromwell of Oakham
|
---|
214 | <br><b><font color="#990000">1537</font></b> - Knight of the Garter and
|
---|
215 | Dean of Wells
|
---|
216 | <br><b><font color="#990000">1539</font></b> - Lord Great Chamberlain
|
---|
217 | <br><b><font color="#990000">1540</font></b> - created Earl of Essex
|
---|
218 | <p> As the above list shows, Henry never forgot the fallen
|
---|
219 | Wolsey. He had heaped honors upon him with extravagant generosity
|
---|
220 | and had written to the pope recommending religious promotion. In
|
---|
221 | the end, Henry believed himself betrayed. Not only had Wolsey accumulated
|
---|
222 | obscene wealth, but he had grown arrogant and eventually treasonous.
|
---|
223 | And so Cromwell, despite his years of diligence and genius, was eventually
|
---|
224 | rewarded with an earldom but only a short time before his execution.
|
---|
225 | <p> His influence upon the 1530s, one of the most influential
|
---|
226 | and vital decades in English history, was enormous. One needs only
|
---|
227 | to study the 1540s to realize how the loss of Cromwell affected Tudor government.
|
---|
228 | He also came to power during Anne Boleyn's ascendancy. It was a symbolic
|
---|
229 | changing of the guard - the old Katharine of Aragon thrust aside for the
|
---|
230 | young, ambitious Anne Boleyn and Wolsey disgraced and replaced by his protégé
|
---|
231 | Cromwell. Cromwell supported Anne until she, like Wolsey, became
|
---|
232 | a liability. Among his immediate accomplishments were the following:
|
---|
233 | <br><b><font color="#990000">1</font></b> - the dissolution of the monasteries
|
---|
234 | and establishment of the royal supremacy
|
---|
235 | <br><b><font color="#990000">2</font></b> - founded the ministries of Augmentations
|
---|
236 | and First Fruits to handle income from the dissolution
|
---|
237 | <br><b><font color="#990000">3</font></b> - founded the two courts of Wards
|
---|
238 | and Surveyors which allowed more efficient taxation and leasing
|
---|
239 | <br><b><font color="#990000">4 </font></b>- politically integrated the
|
---|
240 | kingdom by extending sovereign authority into northern England, Wales &
|
---|
241 | Ireland (actions which angered the great feudal lords)
|
---|
242 | <br><b><font color="#990000">5</font></b> - used the power of that relatively
|
---|
243 | new invention, the printing-press and thus spearheaded the first propaganda
|
---|
244 | campaign in English history.
|
---|
245 | <p> In the 1530s, he had instituted reforms of the English
|
---|
246 | government which earned enmity from the nobility. Cromwell recognized
|
---|
247 | the basic inefficiency of feudal government and, from it, struggled to
|
---|
248 | create a more logical system. Instead of offices held solely because
|
---|
249 | of birth, he wanted trained servants with expertise in their field.
|
---|
250 | He built a bureaucracy of professionals outside the royal household.
|
---|
251 | He began the first era of parliamentary control of England, using the institution
|
---|
252 | to dissolve the monasteries which made up a quarter of all arable land
|
---|
253 | and validate his other decisions.
|
---|
254 | <p> From the above list, one will note that most of the
|
---|
255 | 'accomplishments' were motivated by financial need. Like his predecessors
|
---|
256 | in government ministry, Cromwell needed to provide secure and regular income.
|
---|
257 | This alone necessitated an assault on the church's wealth. Cromwell
|
---|
258 | also developed a novel, and very unpopular idea - in the past, taxes were
|
---|
259 | created to support warfare; in 1534, he developed a new tax. Its
|
---|
260 | basis? The king's maintenance of peace. These measures did
|
---|
261 | not help his reputation but, by 1547, had brought nearly 2,000,000 pds
|
---|
262 | to Henry's treasury. Of course, Henry would use the entire windfall
|
---|
263 | to finance his increasingly complicated foreign policy. At the time
|
---|
264 | of Henry's death, all the wealth Cromwell had accumulated was gone and
|
---|
265 | Edward VI was left with debased currency and massive debts.
|
---|
266 | <p> In 1534, however, Henry was prepared to reap the
|
---|
267 | benefits of his new anti-clerical policies. He had appointed his
|
---|
268 | friend Thomas Cranmer to the venerable and powerful position of Archbishop
|
---|
269 | of Canterbury. Cranmer was like Cromwell in many ways - both owed
|
---|
270 | their rise to prominence entirely to Henry's mercurial favor; both came
|
---|
271 | from humble backgrounds; both were despised by the traditional nobility.
|
---|
272 | Cranmer had come to Henry's attention by first suggesting a solution to
|
---|
273 | the divorce problem - petition learned churchmen for their opinion, assuming
|
---|
274 | they agreed with Henry. Like Cromwell, Cranmer benefited directly
|
---|
275 | from the fall of Katharine of Aragon and the Imperial alliance and the
|
---|
276 | rise of Anne Boleyn and her Norfolk relations. Henry's midlife crisis
|
---|
277 | provided fertile ground for ambitious men. Cranmer and Cromwell liked
|
---|
278 | one another and became friends, though Cranmer was careful to distance
|
---|
279 | himself once Cromwell's ruin was assured.
|
---|
280 | <p> In 1535, Henry appointed Cromwell Vicar General and,
|
---|
281 | over the next five years, the honors increased - Lord Privy Seal, titled
|
---|
282 | Baron Cromwell of Oakham, Knight of the Garter and Dean of Wells, and finally
|
---|
283 | Lord Great Chancellor and ennoblement as Earl of Essex. The last
|
---|
284 | was Cromwell's greatest ambition and long before justified by his superior
|
---|
285 | service to the crown. During the accumulation of these honors, however,
|
---|
286 | Cromwell began to recognize the flaws in his success.
|
---|
287 | <p> First, he had accompanied Anne Boleyn on her rise
|
---|
288 | to power; yet, in 1536, he helped engineer her disgrace and execution on
|
---|
289 | charges of adultery, incest, and witchcraft. Why? Cromwell
|
---|
290 | recognized Henry's dissatisfaction with the marriage - after several years,
|
---|
291 | Anne's sharp tongue had offended many and, even worse, she had not produced
|
---|
292 | a male heir. Furthermore, Henry had become infatuated with Anne's
|
---|
293 | lady-in-waiting, Mistress Jane Seymour. Tiring of his wife, he wanted
|
---|
294 | to be rid of her. Divorce was only briefly considered before being
|
---|
295 | pushed aside. As he had with Katharine of Aragon, Henry became convinced
|
---|
296 | his marriage was invalid, only this time because of adultery, and he retained
|
---|
297 | his absolute conviction in her guilt even as he truly believed his and
|
---|
298 | Katharine's marriage was invalid. To rid himself of Anne, he turned
|
---|
299 | to the ever-ready Cromwell. Soon enough, Anne was on trial with her
|
---|
300 | brother and two male servants. They were all executed, despite spirited
|
---|
301 | defenses and the widely-held belief that it was judicial murder.
|
---|
302 | <p> Cromwell betrayed his former patron because she no
|
---|
303 | longer held the king's favor. In the rough world of Tudor politics,
|
---|
304 | friendships were lost in the struggle for prestige and survival.
|
---|
305 | And now Cromwell turned to Mistress Jane Seymour and her relatively obscure
|
---|
306 | family for support. The Seymours, however, never warmed to Cromwell
|
---|
307 | as had the Boleyns, largely because they didn't trust him or his influence
|
---|
308 | over the king. Cromwell was careful to press Jane's cause to the
|
---|
309 | king though Henry needed little urging. Just days after Anne Boleyn's
|
---|
310 | execution, Jane Seymour became his third wife, dying eighteen months later
|
---|
311 | after delivering the longed-for son, Prince Edward. Cromwell busied
|
---|
312 | himself with auctioning off church properties to various noblemen and further
|
---|
313 | reforming the archaic machinery of Tudor government. In doing so,
|
---|
314 | he continued to ignore Henry's council of noble peers. When the council
|
---|
315 | did meet, Cromwell dominated the meetings and disregarded most suggestions.
|
---|
316 | To his credit, he was right on most counts; the nobility was quite distanced
|
---|
317 | from the changing nature of government. They were fiercely protective
|
---|
318 | of their own 'inalienable' rights as landowners and peers and notoriously
|
---|
319 | difficult when these rights were impugned (this conflict between the nobility
|
---|
320 | and monarchy was centuries-old - simply remember the 13th century <i>Magna
|
---|
321 | Carta</i>, when the nobles forced King John I to recognize their 'natural'
|
---|
322 | rights.)
|
---|
323 | <p> As discussed earlier, the nobility resented Cromwell's
|
---|
324 | influence with the king and his pro-monarchy, anti-nobility policy.
|
---|
325 | And while many of the nobles benefited from the sale of clerical lands,
|
---|
326 | many others had relatives dedicated to religious service. Also, reverence
|
---|
327 | for the church and its servants was as deeply-held as reverence for the
|
---|
328 | monarchy. Henry's attacks upon the church struck many as unnatural
|
---|
329 | and wrong; since they could not turn on the king, they turned on Cromwell
|
---|
330 | and blamed him for every unpopular policy. Henry VIII, who relished
|
---|
331 | his popularity, allowed his faithful servant to be impugned. Thus,
|
---|
332 | Henry could meet with his nobles, listen to their complaints, and even
|
---|
333 | agree with them since many were his dearest friends. The king remained
|
---|
334 | popular while his chief minister became increasingly despised and isolated.
|
---|
335 | It is worth noting that one of Cromwell's friends, Richard Moryson, argued
|
---|
336 | that merit and not birth should be the only qualification for entry into
|
---|
337 | the privy council. Moryson eventually became a member himself.
|
---|
338 | <p> It is also important to note that years of listening
|
---|
339 | to anti-Cromwell gossip eventually affected Henry. Even the king
|
---|
340 | did not exist in a vacuum and, as his temper became increasingly erratic,
|
---|
341 | he was easily swayed by inflamed opinion. Thus, Cromwell suffered
|
---|
342 | from a lapse in Henry's temper and one which the king almost immediately
|
---|
343 | regretted. Chief among Cromwell's enemies were the highest nobles
|
---|
344 | in the land, once Wolsey's great enemies and led by the dukes of Suffolk
|
---|
345 | and Norfolk. These men had pushed Wolsey from favor after years of
|
---|
346 | effort and were determined to do the same to his protégé.
|
---|
347 | The perfect opportunity arrived when Queen Jane died two weeks after childbirth,
|
---|
348 | in October 1537. Henry VIII was genuinely bereaved at her death but
|
---|
349 | almost immediately the search began for a new queen. After all, Jane
|
---|
350 | had delivered a son but one male heir was not enough in the sixteenth century.
|
---|
351 | Henry's council began to search for a new consort with the king's enthusiastic
|
---|
352 | support.
|
---|
353 | <p> For Cromwell, this was a chance to further extend
|
---|
354 | his influence while thwarting the English nobility. Henry's second
|
---|
355 | and third wives had been English noblewomen whose families directly profited
|
---|
356 | from their rise to power. The influence of these families naturally
|
---|
357 | troubled Cromwell. As their influence rose, his own suffered - so
|
---|
358 | he was opposed to the idea of another English wife. Also, as an intelligent
|
---|
359 | statesman, he recognized the diplomatic power of royal marriages.
|
---|
360 | Henry's troublesome foreign policy could be soothed if he chose a foreign
|
---|
361 | wife - a princess or duchess of one of the great European families.
|
---|
362 | Kings were meant to marry other royalty and Cromwell immediately searched
|
---|
363 | for possible candidates.
|
---|
364 | <p> While searching, he was careful to avoid Catholic
|
---|
365 | candidates. Cromwell's rise to power was directly connected to the
|
---|
366 | fall of Catholicism in England and he wanted to keep England on the path
|
---|
367 | of Protestantism. Therefore, he sought a Protestant ally for Henry
|
---|
368 | VIII. Naturally, his gaze turned to the Protestant states of Germany,
|
---|
369 | birthplace of the Lutheran revolution. Meanwhile, Henry VIII was
|
---|
370 | concerned with more aesthetic matters, sending artists (most famously,
|
---|
371 | Hans Holbein the Younger) to France and Milan to paint potential brides.
|
---|
372 | Among those painted was Christina, duchess of Milan and niece of the Holy
|
---|
373 | Roman Emperor; she famously remarked that she would be happy to marry Henry
|
---|
374 | - if she had two heads! Henry also considered Marie de Guise, a widowed
|
---|
375 | cousin of the French king. Marie, however, chose to marry Henry's
|
---|
376 | nephew, James V of Scotland, thus creating a French-Scottish alliance along
|
---|
377 | Henry's troublesome northern border. Their only surviving child is
|
---|
378 | famous in history as the tragic Mary queen of Scots.
|
---|
379 | <p> Cromwell was well aware that if France and the Holy
|
---|
380 | Roman Empire ended hostilities, as seemed likely, England would be left
|
---|
381 | out in the diplomatic cold. He was quite happy when the French and
|
---|
382 | Imperial marriage negotiations fell apart. But as the search wound
|
---|
383 | on, Henry became increasingly desperate for a wife. No doubt he was
|
---|
384 | lonely; also, his court needed a queen to be complete. A king was
|
---|
385 | not meant to be a bachelor, as every European monarch knew. Finally,
|
---|
386 | Cromwell found a Protestant ally with two available sisters - the duke
|
---|
387 | of Cleves, whose lands were strategically located and wealthy. He
|
---|
388 | had two sisters not yet wed called Anne and Amelia. As the eldest,
|
---|
389 | Anne was chosen as the possible bride and Holbein immediately went to Cleves
|
---|
390 | to paint her portrait. <a href="http://www.geocities.com/athens/forum/9194/cleves1.jpg">This
|
---|
391 | painting</a> would become of paramount importance in the coming year.
|
---|
392 | Henry was determined to have a beautiful wife and specifically asked his
|
---|
393 | various ambassadors probing questions - does Marie de Guise have wide hips
|
---|
394 | for childbearing? is Christina of Milan pock-marked? does Anne of Cleves
|
---|
395 | play the lute? Holbein's famous portrait of Anne cannot be adequately
|
---|
396 | judged in our time; after all, standards of beauty have changed.
|
---|
397 | However, it is amusing to note that she - so maligned in her own time as
|
---|
398 | the ugliest of Henry's wives - is the most attractive by twentieth-century
|
---|
399 | standards.
|
---|
400 | <p> Holbein's portrait showed a perfectly attractive
|
---|
401 | young woman - and, on that basis, Cromwell was able to secure the marriage
|
---|
402 | alliance with a Protestant ally. Anne set sail for England, little
|
---|
403 | realizing what lay ahead. The king, meanwhile, was ecstatic that
|
---|
404 | after almost three years as a widower he would be a husband again, able
|
---|
405 | to play one of his favorite roles. The entire country was thrilled
|
---|
406 | at the news, in fact, and after Anne arrived, Cromwell finally secured
|
---|
407 | his greatest ambition - an earldom. He was titled earl of Essex by
|
---|
408 | Henry VIII on 18 April 1540 after the marriage treaty was finalized.
|
---|
409 | <p> During this time, he also attempted to placate the
|
---|
410 | nobility by redistributing lands to the great magnates, providing them
|
---|
411 | with near-autonomous controls of great sections of land. For example,
|
---|
412 | the duke of Suffolk traded East Anglian lands for lands in Lincolnshire
|
---|
413 | - the duke of Norfolk already held lands in Anglia while Lincolnshire needed
|
---|
414 | a strong leader. Earlier, Cromwell had attempted to befriend Henry's
|
---|
415 | oldest child, the stubbornly Catholic Princess Mary. She rebuffed
|
---|
416 | his attention, largely on religious grounds.
|
---|
417 | <p> Two years of marriage-brokering were often interrupted
|
---|
418 | by rumors of rebellion. The Pilgrimage of Grace had made Henry more
|
---|
419 | sensitive to popular sentiment. While Cromwell searched for a wife,
|
---|
420 | rumors spread that the king planned new taxes. Also, the last remnants
|
---|
421 | of the legitimate Plantagenet line - the Nevilles, Poles, and Courtenays
|
---|
422 | - were suspected of encouraging rebellionn and Henry used this convenient
|
---|
423 | excuse to order more executions. But popular unrest needed to be
|
---|
424 | assuaged in some manner so Cromwell engineered the passing of the Six Articles
|
---|
425 | at Parliament in April 1539. These articles attempted to stamp a
|
---|
426 | more conservative gloss on the Henrician reformation, thus placating conservative
|
---|
427 | European nobles - and the Catholic nations in Europe, now forced to concede
|
---|
428 | Henry was not so great a heretic after all. It was a supreme example
|
---|
429 | of Cromwell's talent for diffusing domestic tension. In effect, it
|
---|
430 | was all talk and no action; it didn't alter the course of the reformation
|
---|
431 | one bit.
|
---|
432 | <p> Finally, on 6 October 1539, the marriage treaty with
|
---|
433 | Cleves was finalized just two months after Holbein delivered his portrait.
|
---|
434 | Princess Anne, once betrothed to the duke of Lorraine, was now destined
|
---|
435 | to be queen of England. It was the fulfillment of Cromwell's domestic
|
---|
436 | and foreign policies. On 11 December, Anne was at Calais waiting
|
---|
437 | for a favorable wind to carry her to Dover. She was there for almost
|
---|
438 | two weeks while Henry waited at Greenwich. Finally, on 27 December
|
---|
439 | she landed at Deal and then traveled to Dover and Canterbury before arriving
|
---|
440 | at Rochester on 1 January 1540. Henry, desperate to see his bride
|
---|
441 | in person, rushed in disguise to meet her 'to thus nourish love', he told
|
---|
442 | Cromwell. Their comical first meeting is described at the <a href="../primary.html">Primary
|
---|
443 | Sources</a> section.
|
---|
444 | <p> The meeting was an unmitigated disaster and the beginning
|
---|
445 | of Cromwell's end. The New Year gifts Henry had brought for Anne
|
---|
446 | were delivered the next day by a courier with a brief note of welcome.
|
---|
447 | 'I am ashamed that men have so praised her as they have done, and I like
|
---|
448 | her not', the king said ominously; he told Cromwell that Anne was 'nothing
|
---|
449 | so well as she was spoken of' and, if he had known the truth of her appearance,
|
---|
450 | she would never have come to England. The next day, his betrothed
|
---|
451 | arrived in Greenwich and the marriage, scheduled for that day, was delayed
|
---|
452 | for two days while Henry sought escape. But there was none to be
|
---|
453 | had - the Holy Roman Emperor was in Paris meeting with the French king
|
---|
454 | and Henry, locked out by those two great powers, could not risk offending
|
---|
455 | the German princes who approved the union with Anne. They were, after
|
---|
456 | all, his only allies at the moment. So Anne was not sent back and
|
---|
457 | Henry moaned that he must 'put my neck in the yoke'. He wrote to
|
---|
458 | Cromwell, 'My lord, if it were not to satisfy the world and my realm, I
|
---|
459 | would not do that I must do this day for none earthly thing'.
|
---|
460 | <p> Poor Anne of Cleves - barely able to speak English,
|
---|
461 | in a foreign land, and despised by her intended husband! The confused
|
---|
462 | woman was led to a private marriage ceremony at Greenwich and, then, to
|
---|
463 | her equally humiliating marriage-bed. The union was not consummated,
|
---|
464 | a subject upon which Henry never wavered. He spoke openly of how
|
---|
465 | disgusted he was by Anne's appearance; 'struck to the heart' by distaste,
|
---|
466 | he 'left her as good a maid as he found her'. They lay together for
|
---|
467 | the entire length of their marriage but were never physically intimate.
|
---|
468 | After a few months had passed, the French-Imperial alliance showed signs
|
---|
469 | of cooling and Henry's natural boldness had returned. He wanted out
|
---|
470 | of this fourth marriage and told Cromwell to arrange it.
|
---|
471 | <p> What were Cromwell's options? There were two
|
---|
472 | ways to nullify the marriage (in essence, arrange a divorce) - Henry had
|
---|
473 | not consented to the marriage (this was proved by his failure to consummate
|
---|
474 | it) and Anne had not consented to the marriage (this was proved by Anne's
|
---|
475 | precontract to the duke of Lorraine.) Henry had long been concerned
|
---|
476 | with the latter problem - but had been assured that the contract was completely
|
---|
477 | repudiated. Still, the day before his marriage to Anne, he called
|
---|
478 | the Clevian ambassadors to him and raised the issue. They were astonished,
|
---|
479 | and rightly so, and offered to remain as prisoners in England until the
|
---|
480 | formal repudiation papers were delivered from Cleves. Meanwhile,
|
---|
481 | Thomas Cranmer told the king that Anne could simply swear that the betrothal
|
---|
482 | had been repudiated - no official documents were necessary. His friend
|
---|
483 | Cromwell 'travailed on him [Henry] to pass the matter over'; he hoped that
|
---|
484 | once Henry was married to Anne, the king would resign himself to the marriage.
|
---|
485 | <p> But instead Henry turned to the precontract when
|
---|
486 | his distaste could not be overcome. On 9 July, Parliament declared
|
---|
487 | the marriage null and void and Anne, surprising Henry and the court, was
|
---|
488 | content to be called 'sister' and receive a handsome income and household
|
---|
489 | in England. She had no desire to return to Cleves, where she would
|
---|
490 | remain under her brother's thumb and perhaps married again. It is
|
---|
491 | also possible she found Henry as unattractive as he found her. Henry
|
---|
492 | was so pleased with this unexpected docility that he gave her status second
|
---|
493 | only to his daughters, Princesses Mary and Elizabeth, both of whom came
|
---|
494 | to befriend Anne. Anne's letter to Henry, in which she accepts the
|
---|
495 | dissolution of their marriage, can be read at '<a href="../letters.html">Letters
|
---|
496 | of the Six Wives of Henry VIII</a>'.
|
---|
497 | <p> However, the time had come to search for a convenient
|
---|
498 | scapegoat - the person responsible for the disastrous union. Henry
|
---|
499 | railed against his ambassadors who had so misled him with descriptions
|
---|
500 | of her beauty - though, in truth, the ambassador's descriptions had been
|
---|
501 | honest. It was soon alleged that Cromwell had kept them from the
|
---|
502 | king, for fear of discouraging the union. Now, Cromwell was arrested
|
---|
503 | on 10 June 1540, at 3pm on a Saturday, while at a Privy Council meeting.
|
---|
504 | This was a full month before the marriage was nullified. Henry and
|
---|
505 | Cromwell's enemies were in the midst of finding scapegoats for the marriage,
|
---|
506 | while not yet assured of its outcome. Henry, in a fit of temper and
|
---|
507 | pique, complained bitterly that his minister had betrayed him while trying
|
---|
508 | to further his own influence; the nobility were only too happy to encourage
|
---|
509 | such thoughts. They urged Henry to arrest Cromwell and teach the
|
---|
510 | upstart his final lesson - namely, that it does not pay to mislead a king.
|
---|
511 | <p> So the captain of the guard arrived at the council
|
---|
512 | chamber and arrested Cromwell, while a table of his enemies looked on.
|
---|
513 | The moment the guard entered the room, Cromwell recognized the danger -
|
---|
514 | and threw his hat upon the table in rage. Norfolk and Southampton
|
---|
515 | stripped his decorations from his robe of state and Cromwell was then escorted
|
---|
516 | to a barge - and, then, the Tower of London. The events which follow
|
---|
517 | are far from clear - Cromwell's fall and execution are among the most mysterious
|
---|
518 | events of Henry VIII's reign and cannot be easily understood. I have
|
---|
519 | yet to read a history which offers an adequate explanation. In truth,
|
---|
520 | Henry became increasingly mercurial and tempermental in his later years,
|
---|
521 | and Cromwell was just one of many victims of the king's ever-changing whims.
|
---|
522 | <p><font size=+1> </font> First, if Cromwell fell from favor because
|
---|
523 | of the Cleves marriage, as most believe, why did Henry title him earl of
|
---|
524 | Essex in April 1540 - months after the marriage had been finalized and
|
---|
525 | while negotiations for divorce were underway? Second, if Cromwell
|
---|
526 | was executed because his government policies angered the king, as has been
|
---|
527 | alleged, why did Henry give his voluntary approval to all of Cromwell's
|
---|
528 | legislation? Third, is his enemies were in the ascendancy, why had
|
---|
529 | Henry only recently shown the duke of Norfolk (Cromwell's great enemy)
|
---|
530 | open favor? After all, Norfolk had just been sent abroad on diplomatic
|
---|
531 | work - away from the king.
|
---|
532 | <p> What are we left with? The charges eventually
|
---|
533 | listed in Cromwell's attainder <i>did not</i> list the above - Cromwell
|
---|
534 | was not accused of misleading Henry on matters of policy, he was not held
|
---|
535 | responsible for the disastrous marriage, and he was not charged with leading
|
---|
536 | England into an unwanted Lutheran alliance. Instead, he was charged
|
---|
537 | with selling export licenses illegally, granting passports and commissions
|
---|
538 | without royal knowledge, freeing people suspected of treason and - of course
|
---|
539 | - that he, base-born and ignoble, had usuurped and deliberately misused
|
---|
540 | royal power. Most significantly, however, he was charged with heresy
|
---|
541 | - this charge was the bulk of his attaindder and apparently swayed Henry
|
---|
542 | decisively. Norfolk, allied with the Catholic bishops Cromwell had
|
---|
543 | forced from power, engineered this charge. Cromwell, they charged,
|
---|
544 | had encouraged and spread heretical literature, allowed heretics to preach,
|
---|
545 | released them from prison, and allied himself against their enemies.
|
---|
546 | Significantly, it was reported that in March 1539 Cromwell said that, even
|
---|
547 | if Henry turned from Protestantism, 'yet I would not turn, and if the king
|
---|
548 | did turn, and all his people, I would fight in this field in mine own person,
|
---|
549 | with my sword in my hand <i>against him</i> and all other'. That
|
---|
550 | was treason.
|
---|
551 | <p> Shortly after his arrest, incriminating letters to
|
---|
552 | Lutherans were found in Cromwell's home, placed there by agents of the
|
---|
553 | duke of Norfolk; they were so inflammatory that the king was outraged.
|
---|
554 | Cromwell's name, Henry swore, would be abolished forever. Cromwell
|
---|
555 | wrote two desperate letters from the Tower; the one that survives is in
|
---|
556 | tatters. He assured his monarch that he was a good, loyal servant
|
---|
557 | and a faithful Christian. But Henry, surrounded by Cromwell's enemies
|
---|
558 | and - more significantly - newly infatuated with Norfolk's niece, Catherine
|
---|
559 | Howard, would hear nothing. Furthermore, Norfolk was shrewd enough
|
---|
560 | to create a Lutheran conspiracy; three popular reformers, Robert Barnes,
|
---|
561 | Thomas Garret, and William Jerome, were executed just days after Cromwell.
|
---|
562 | None of the men were allowed an open trial. That would allow the
|
---|
563 | public opportunity for them to dispute the false charges. Instead,
|
---|
564 | they were condemned by Act of Attainder, a parliamentary tool which dispensed
|
---|
565 | with justice in favor of speed.
|
---|
566 | <p> The executed men were also neighbors of Cromwell,
|
---|
567 | which was their only link to the earl. And they were as innocent
|
---|
568 | as Cromwell of the charges against them - as evidenced by the confusion
|
---|
569 | of contemporary chroniclers. Edward Hall, one of the great chroniclers
|
---|
570 | of Tudor England, could find no real evidence against them although he
|
---|
571 | 'searched to know the truth'.
|
---|
572 | <p> So Cromwell was executed privately on Tower Green
|
---|
573 | on 28 July 1540, still protesting his innocence. He died with dignity
|
---|
574 | - but the whole sordid affair of his deatth would not rest. For the
|
---|
575 | volatile Henry VIII was soon despairing of his loss, just a few months
|
---|
576 | after he allowed the execution. He raged at his council, accusing
|
---|
577 | them of lying and deliberately destroying his 'most faithful servant'.
|
---|
578 | Cromwell's destruction had been engineered on 'light pretexts' and against
|
---|
579 | the king's wishes. In truth, Henry was a victim as well - of a determined
|
---|
580 | group of nobles and clerics, led by Norfolk, who hated Cromwell and carried
|
---|
581 | the king along on their path of destruction. Events were rapid and
|
---|
582 | deliberately confused. By the time Henry realized what had happened,
|
---|
583 | it was too late. He could only bemoan his loss, while never understanding
|
---|
584 | exactly why it happened.
|
---|
585 | <p> This was no comfort to Thomas Cromwell, however;
|
---|
586 | after a lifetime of dedicated service, he met his end by execution and
|
---|
587 | all of Henry's regrets could not bring him back to life.
|
---|
588 | <center>
|
---|
589 | <hr WIDTH="100%">
|
---|
590 | <br><font size=-1><a href="../citizens.html">to
|
---|
591 | Tudor Citizens</a></font>
|
---|
592 | <br><font size=-1><a href="http://englishhistory.net/tudor.html">to Tudor
|
---|
593 | England</a></font>
|
---|
594 | <p><b><font size=-1>Want to learn more about Cromwell?</font></b>
|
---|
595 | <br><font size=-1>Try these books (used as sources for my article) -</font>
|
---|
596 | <br><font size=-1>The Cardinal and the Secretary: Thomas Wolsey and Thomas
|
---|
597 | Cromwell</font>
|
---|
598 | <br><font size=-1>by Neville Williams.</font>
|
---|
599 | <br><font size=-1>Policy and Police: the enforcement of the Reformation
|
---|
600 | in the Age of Thomas Cromwell</font>
|
---|
601 | <br><font size=-1>by G. R. Elton.</font>
|
---|
602 | <br><font size=-1>Reform and Renewal: Thomas Cromwell and the Common Weal</font>
|
---|
603 | <br><font size=-1>by G. R. Elton.</font>
|
---|
604 | <br><font size=-1>Thomas Cromwell and the English Reformation</font>
|
---|
605 | <br><font size=-1>by A. G. Dickens.</font>
|
---|
606 | <br><font size=-1>Thomas Cromwell: Tudor Minister</font>
|
---|
607 | <br><font size=-1>by B. W. Beckingsale.</font></center>
|
---|
608 |
|
---|
609 | </body>
|
---|
610 | </html>
|
---|
611 | <!-- text below generated by server. PLEASE REMOVE --><!-- Counter/Statistics data collection code --><script language="JavaScript" src="http://hostingprod.com/js_source/geov2.js"></script><script language="javascript">geovisit();</script><noscript><img src="http://visit.webhosting.yahoo.com/visit.gif?us1108082581" alt="setstats" border="0" width="1" height="1"></noscript>
|
---|
612 | <IMG SRC="http://geo.yahoo.com/serv?s=76001524&t=1108082581" ALT=1 WIDTH=1 HEIGHT=1>
|
---|