source: other-projects/nightly-tasks/diffcol/trunk/model-collect/Tudor-Enhanced/import/englishhistory.net/tudor/beeslychaptertwo.html@ 27993

Last change on this file since 27993 was 27993, checked in by ak19, 11 years ago

Adding collections for Tudor tutorials that Jenny had gone through, with the flags necessary for diffcol to work.

  • Property svn:executable set to *
File size: 22.6 KB
Line 
1<html>
2
3<head>
4<meta name="content" content="biography of Queen Elizabeth I (1533-1603) by Edward Spencer Beesly, 1892">
5<meta name="page_topic" content="biography of Queen Elizabeth I (1533-1603) by Edward Spencer Beesly, 1892">
6<meta name="author" content="Marilee Mongello">
7<meta name="GENERATOR" content="Microsoft FrontPage 5.0">
8<meta name="ProgId" content="FrontPage.Editor.Document">
9<meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=windows-1252">
10<meta http-equiv="Content-Language" content="en-us">
11<title>Secondary Sources: Queen Elizabeth by Edward Spencer Beesly, 1892:
12Chapter II</title>
13<style>
14</style>
15<style fprolloverstyle>A:hover {color: #0000FF; font-weight: bold}
16.3text {font-size: 12 px;}
17</style>
18</head>
19
20<body link="#0000FF" vlink="#0000FF" alink="#0000FF">
21
22<table border="0" cellpadding="3" width="100%" height="667">
23 <tr>
24 <td width="25%" height="29"></td>
25 <td valign="top" width="50%" height="29">&nbsp;</td>
26 <td width="25%" height="29"></td>
27 </tr>
28 <tr>
29 <td width="25%" height="3"></td>
30 <td width="50%" height="3"><font size="3"></font></td>
31 <td width="25%" height="3"></td>
32 </tr>
33 <tr>
34 <td width="25%" height="610"></td>
35 <td valign="top" width="50%" height="610">
36 <p align="center"><b><font size="7">Queen Elizabeth<br></font></b>
37 <font size="4">by Edward Spencer Beesly, 1892</font></p>
38 <p align="center">
39 <img border="2" src="eliz1-ermine.jpg" width="400" height="478" alt="'The Ermine Portrait' of Elizabeth I, c1585, by Nicholas Hilliard"><p align="center">
40 <i><font size="2">'The Ermine Portrait' of Elizabeth I, c1585, by Nicholas
41 Hilliard;<br>from the <a href="http://www.marileecody.com/eliz1-images.html">Portraits of Queen Elizabeth I</a> website</font></i></td>
42 <td width="25%" height="610"></td>
43 </tr>
44</table>
45<blockquote>
46 <blockquote>
47 <font style="font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif">
48 <font style="font-family: Times New Roman"></font>
49 <font style="font-family: Times New Roman">
50 <div align="left">
51 <b>CHAPTER II</b><br>
52 <b>THE CHANGE OF RELIGION: 1559</b></div>
53 <p align="left"><font size="3">MARY died on the 17th of November 1558.
54 Parliament was then sitting, and, in communicating the event to both Houses,
55 Archbishop Heath frankly took the initiative in recognising
56 <font class="highlight_yellow">Elizabeth</font>, &quot;of whose most lawful right
57 and title in the succession of the Crown, thanks be to God, we need not to
58 doubt.&quot; He was a staunch Catholic, and two months later refused to officiate
59 at her coronation. But he was an Englishman, and even the most convinced
60 Catholics, though looking forward with uneasiness to the religious policy of
61 the new <font class="highlight_yellow">Queen</font>, were sincerely glad
62 that there was no danger of a disputed succession. Besides, it was by no
63 means clear that <font class="highlight_yellow">Elizabeth</font> would not
64 accept the ecclesiastical constitution as established in the late reign.
65 That there would be an end of burnings, and of the harassing tyranny of the
66 bishops, every one felt certain; but it seemed quite upon the cards that
67 <font class="highlight_yellow">Elizabeth</font> would continue to recognise
68 the headship of the Pope in a formal way and maintain the Mass. It must be
69 remembered that the religious changes had only begun some thirty years
70 before. All middle-aged men could remember the time when the ecclesiastical
71 fabric stood to all appearance unbroken, as it had stood for centuries. Only
72 twenty-four years had passed since the Act of Supremacy had transferred the
73 headship of the Church from the Pope to the King; only eleven since the
74 Protestant doctrine and worship had been forced on the country by the
75 Protector Somerset, to the horror and disgust of the great majority of
76 Englishmen. The nation had sorrowed for the death of Edward VI., because it
77 darkened the prospects of the succession, and seemed likely sooner or later
78 to bring on a civil war. But apart from the hot Protestant minority, chiefly
79 to be found in London, the mass of the nation was conservative, and welcomed
80 the reestablishment of the old religion as a return to order and common
81 sense after a short and bitter experience of revolutionary anarchy. There
82 was a rooted objection to restore the old meddlesome tyranny of the bishops,
83 and the nobles and squires who had got hold of the abbey lands would not
84 hear of giving them up. But the return to communion with the Catholic Church
85 and the recognition of the Pope as its head gave satisfaction to
86 three-fourths, perhaps to five-sixths, of the nation, and to a still larger
87 proportion of its most influential class, the great landed proprietors.
88 Mary's accession was the great and unique opportunity for the old Church. If
89 Mary and Pole had been coolheaded politicians instead of excitable fanatics,
90 if they had contented themselves with restoring the old worship, depriving
91 the few Protestant clergy of their benefices, and punishing only outrageous
92 attacks on the State religion, Elizabeth would not have had the power, it
93 may be doubted whether she would have had the inclination, to undo her
94 sister's work. </font></p>
95 <p align="left"><font size="3">This great opportunity was thrown away.
96 Mary's bishops came back brooding over the long catalogue of humiliations
97 and indignities which their Church had suffered, and thirsting to avenge
98 their own wrongs. For six years they had their fling, and contrived to make
99 the country forget the period of Protestant misgovernment. England had never
100 before known what it was to be governed by clergymen. It was a sort of rule
101 as hateful to most Catholic laymen as to Protestants. Catholics therefore
102 for the most part, as well as Protestants, hailed the accession of
103 Elizabeth. At any rate there would be an end of the clerical tyranny. Nor
104 were they without hope that she would maintain the old worship. She had
105 conformed to it for the last five years, and Philip had given the word that
106 she was to be supported. </font></p>
107 <p align="left"><font size="3">We are now accustomed to the Papal <i>non
108 possumus</i>. No nation or Church can hope that the smallest deviation from
109 Roman doctrine or discipline will be tolerated. But in 1558 the hard and
110 fast line had not yet been drawn. France was still pressing for such changes
111 as communion in both kinds, worship in the vulgar tongue, and marriage of
112 priests. The Council of Trent, it is true, had already in 1545 decided that
113 Catholic doctrine was contained in the Bible <i>and tradition</i>, and in
114 1551 had defined transubstantiation and the sacraments. But in 1552 the
115 Council was prorogued, and it did not resume till 1562. Doctrine and
116 discipline therefore might be, and were still considered to be, in the
117 melting-pot, and no one could be certain what would come out. If Elizabeth
118 had contented herself with the French programme, and had joined France in
119 pressing it, the other sovereigns, who really cared for nothing but
120 uniformity, would probably have forced the Pope to compromise. The Lutheran
121 doctrine of consubstantiation might have been tolerated. The Anglican
122 formulæ have been held by many to be compatible with a belief in the Real
123 Presence. The formal severance of England from Catholic unity might thus
124 have been postponed--possibly avoided--in the same sense that it has been
125 avoided in France. After the completion of the Council of Trent (1562-3) it
126 was too late. </font></p>
127 <p align="left"><font size="3">Two years after her accession Elizabeth told
128 the Spanish ambassador, De Quadra, that her belief was the belief of all the
129 Catholics in the realm; and on his asking her how then she could have
130 altered religion in 1559, she said she had been compelled to act as she did,
131 and that, if he knew how she had been driven to it, she was sure he would
132 excuse her. Seven years later she made the same statement to De Silva.
133 Elizabeth was habitually so regardless of truth that her assertions can be
134 allowed little weight when they are improbable. No doubt, as a matter of
135 taste and feeling, she preferred the Catholic worship. She was not pious.
136 She was not troubled with a tender conscience or tormented by a sense of
137 sin. She did not care to cultivate close personal relations with her God. A
138 religion of form and ceremony suited her better. But her training had been
139 such as to free her from all superstitious fear or prejudice, and her
140 religious convictions were determined by her sense of what was most
141 reasonable and convenient. There is not the least evidence that she was a
142 reluctant agent in the adoption of Protestantism in 1559. Who was there to
143 coerce her? The Protestants could not have set up a Protestant competitor.
144 The great nobles, though opposed to persecution and desirous of minimising
145 the Pope's authority, would have preferred to leave worship as it was. But
146 upon one thing Elizabeth was determined. She would resume the full
147 ecclesiastical supremacy which her father had annexed to the Crown. She
148 judged, and she probably judged rightly, that the only way to assure this
149 was to make the breach with the old religion complete. If she had placed
150 herself in the hands of moderate Catholics like Paget, possessed with the
151 belief that she could only maintain herself by the protection of Philip,
152 they would have advised her to be content with the practical authority over
153 the English Church which many an English king had known how to exercise.
154 That was not enough for her. She desired a position free from all ambiguity
155 and possibility of dispute, not one which would have to be defended with
156 constant vigilance and at the cost of incessant bickering. </font></p>
157 <p align="left"><font size="3">From the point of view of her foreign
158 relations the moment might seem to be a dangerous one for carrying out a
159 religious revolution, and many a statesman with a deserved reputation for
160 prudence would have counselled delay. But this disadvantage was more than
161 counterbalanced by the unpopularity which the cruelties and disasters of
162 Mary's last three years had brought upon the most active Catholics. Again,
163 Elizabeth no doubt recognised that the Catholics, though at present the
164 strongest, were the declining party. The future was with the Protestants. It
165 was the young men who had fixed their hopes upon her in her sister's time,
166 and who were ready to rally round her now. By her natural disposition, and
167 by her culture, she belonged to the Renaissance rather than to the
168 Reformation. But obscurantist as Calvinism essentially was, the Calvinists,
169 as a minority struggling for freedom to think and teach what they believed,
170 represented for a time the cause of light and intellectual emancipation. Was
171 she to put herself at the head of reaction or progress? She did not love the
172 Calvinists. They were too much in earnest for her. Their narrow creed was as
173 tainted with superstition as that of Rome, and, at bottom, was less humane,
174 less favourable to progress. But whom else had she to work with? The
175 reasonable, secular-minded, tolerant sceptics are not always the best
176 fighting material; and at that time they were few in number and tending--in
177 England at least--to be ground out of existence between the upper and nether
178 millstones of the rival fanaticisms. If she broke with Catholicism she would
179 be sure of the ardent and unwavering support of one-third of the nation; so
180 sure, that she would have no need to take any further pains to please them.
181 As for the remaining two-thirds, she hoped to conciliate most of them by
182 posing as their protector against the persecution which would have been
183 pleasing to Protestant bigots. </font></p>
184 <p align="left"><font size="3">In the policy of a complete breach with Rome,
185 Cecil was disposed to go as far as the Queen, and further. Cecil was at this
186 time thirty-eight. For forty years he continued to be the confidential and
187 faithful servant of Elizabeth. One of those new men whom the Tudors most
188 trusted, he was first employed by Henry VIII. Under Edward he rose to be
189 Secretary of State, and was a pronounced Protestant. On the fall of his
190 patron Somerset he was for a abort time sent to the Tower, but was soon in
191 office again--sooner, some thought, than was quite decent--under his
192 patron's old enemy, Northumberland. He signed the letters patent by which
193 the crown was conferred on Lady Jane Grey; but took an early opportunity of
194 going over to Mary. During her reign he conformed to the old religion, and,
195 though not holding any office, was consulted on public business, and was one
196 of the three commissioners who went to fetch Cardinal Pole to England.
197 Thoroughly capable in business, one of those to whom power naturally falls
198 because they know how to use it, a shrewd balancer of probabilities, without
199 a particle of fanaticism in his composition and detesting it in others,
200 though ready to make use of it to serve his ends, entirely believing that &quot;whate'er
201 is best administered is best,&quot; Cecil nevertheless had his religious
202 predilections, and they were all on the side of the Protestants. Moreover he
203 had a personal motive which, by the nature of the case, was not present to
204 the Queen. She might die prematurely; and if that event should take place
205 before the Protestant ascendancy was firmly established his power would be
206 at an end, and his very life would be in danger. A time came when he and his
207 party had so strengthened themselves, if not in absolute numerical
208 superiority, yet by the hold they had established on all departments of
209 Government from the highest to the lowest, that they were in a condition to
210 resist a Catholic claimant to the throne, if need were, sword in hand. But
211 during the early years of the reign Cecil was working with the rope round
212 his neck. Hence he could not regard the progress of events with the
213 imperturbable <i>sang-froid</i> which Elizabeth always displayed; and all
214 his influence was employed to push the religious revolution through as
215 rapidly and completely as possible. </font></p>
216 <p align="left"><font size="3">The story that Elizabeth was influenced in
217 her attitude to Rome by an arrogant reply from Pope Paul IV. to her official
218 notification of her accession, though refuted by Lingard and Hallam in their
219 later editions, has been repeated by recent historians. Her accession was
220 notified to every friendly sovereign except the Pope. He was studiously
221 ignored from the first. Equally unsupported by facts are all attempts to
222 show that during the early weeks of her reign she had not made up her mind
223 as to the course she would take about religion. All preaching, it is true,
224 was suspended by proclamation; and it was ordered that the established
225 worship should go on &quot;until consultation might be had in Parliament by the
226 Queen and the three Estates.&quot; In the meantime she had herself crowned
227 according to the ancient ritual by the Catholic Bishop of Carlisle. But this
228 is only what might have been expected from a strong ruler who was not
229 disposed to let important alterations be initiated by popular commotion or
230 the presumptuous forwardness of individual clergymen. The impending change
231 was quite sufficiently marked from the first by the removal of the most
232 bigoted Catholics from the Council and by the appointment of Cecil and Bacon
233 to the offices of Secretary and of Lord Keeper. The new Parliament,
234 Protestant candidates for which had been recommended by the Government, met
235 as soon as possible (25 January 1559). When it rose (8 May) the great change
236 had been legally and decisively accomplished. </font></p>
237 <p align="left"><font size="3">The government, worship, and doctrine of the
238 Established Church are the most abiding marks left by Elizabeth on the
239 national life of England. Logically it might have been expected that the
240 settlement of doctrine would precede that of government and worship. It is
241 characteristic of a State Church that the inverse order should have been
242 followed. For the Queen the most important question was Church government;
243 for the people, worship. Both these matters were disposed of with great
244 promptitude at the beginning of 1559. Doctrine might interest the clergy;
245 but it could wait. The Thirty-nine Articles were not adopted by Convocation
246 till 1563, and were not sanctioned by Parliament till 1571. </font></p>
247 <p align="left"><font size="3">The government of the Church was settled by
248 the <i>Act of Supremacy (April 1559)</i>. It revived the Act of Henry VIII.,
249 except that the Queen was styled Supreme Governor of the Church instead of
250 Supreme Head, although the nature of the supremacy was precisely the same.
251 The penalties were relaxed. Henry's oath of supremacy might be tendered to
252 any subject, and to decline it was high treason; Elizabeth's oath was to be
253 obligatory only on persons holding spiritual or temporal office under the
254 Crown, and the penalty for declining was the loss of such office. Those who
255 chose to attack the supremacy were still liable to the penalties of treason
256 on the third offence. </font></p>
257 <p align="left"><font size="3">Worship was settled with equal expedition by
258 the <i>Act of Uniformity (April 1559)</i>, which imposed the second or more
259 Protestant Prayer-book of Edward VI., but with a few very important
260 alterations. A deprecation in the Litany of &quot;the tyranny of the Bishop of
261 Rome and all his detestable enormities,&quot; and a rubric which declared that by
262 kneeling at the Communion no adoration was intended to any real and
263 essential presence of Christ, were expunged. The words of administration in
264 the present communion service consist of two sentences. The first sentence,
265 implying real presence, belonged to Edward's first Prayer-book; the second,
266 implying mere commemoration, belonged to his second Prayer-book. The
267 Prayerbook of 1559 simply pieced the two together, with a view to satisfy
268 both Catholics and Protestants. Lastly, the vestments prescribed in Edward's
269 first Prayer-book were retained till further notice. These alterations of
270 Edward's second Prayer-book, all of them designed to propitiate the
271 Catholics, were dictated by Elizabeth herself. In all this legislation
272 Convocation was entirely ignored. Both its houses showed themselves strongly
273 Catholic. But their opinion was not asked, and no notice was taken of their
274 remonstrances. </font></p>
275 <p align="left"><font size="3">While determining that England should have a
276 purely national Church, and for that reason casting in her lot with the
277 Protestants, Elizabeth, as we have seen, made very considerable sacrifices
278 of logic and consistency in order to induce Catholics to conform. Like a
279 strong and wise statesman, she did not allow herself to be driven into one
280 concession after another, but went at once as far as she intended to go. At
281 the same time the coercion applied to the Catholics, while sufficient to
282 influence the worldly-minded majority, was, during the early part of her
283 reign, very mild for those times. She wished no one to be molested who did
284 not go out of his way to invite it. Outward conformity was all she wanted.
285 And of this mere attendance at church was accepted as sufficient evidence.
286 The principal difficulty, of course, was with the clergy. From them more
287 than a mere passive conformity had to be exacted. To sign declarations, take
288 oaths, and officiate in church was a severer strain on the conscience. It is
289 said that less than 200 out of 9400 sacrificed their benefices rather than
290 conform, and that of these about 100 were dignitaries. The number must be
291 under-stated; for the chief difficulty of the new bishops, for a long time,
292 was to find clergymen for the parish churches. But we cannot doubt that the
293 large majority of the parish clergy stuck to their livings, remaining
294 Catholics at heart, and avoiding, where they could, and as long as they
295 could, compliance with the new regulations. It must not be supposed that the
296 enactment of religious changes by Parliament was equivalent, as it would be
297 at the present day, to their immediate enforcement throughout the country;
298 especially in the north where the great proprietors and justices of the
299 peace did not carry out the law. A certain number of the ejected priests
300 continued to celebrate the ancient rites privately in the houses of the more
301 earnest Catholics; for which they were not unfrequently punished by
302 imprisonment. </font></p>
303 <p align="left"><font size="3">Of course this was persecution. But according
304 to the ideas of that day it was a very mild kind of persecution; and where
305 it occurred it seems to have been due to the zeal of some of the bishops,
306 and to private busybodies who set the law in motion, rather than to any
307 systematic action on the part of the Government.</font></p>
308 </font>
309 <hr>
310 <p align="left"><font style="font-family: Times New Roman" size="2">From <i>
311 Queen Elizabeth</i> by Edward Spencer Beesly.&nbsp; Published in London by
312 Macmillan and Co., 1892.</font></p>
313 </font>
314 <font face="Times New Roman" size="2">
315 </blockquote>
316</blockquote>
317
318 <p align="center">
319 <a href="beeslychapterthree.html">to Chapter
320 III: Foreign Relations: 1559-1563</a></p>
321 <p align="center">
322 <a href="monarchs/eliz1.html">to the Queen
323 Elizabeth I website</a>&nbsp; /&nbsp;
324 <a href="relative/maryqos.html">to the Mary,
325 queen of Scots website</a></p>
326 <p align="center"><a href="secondary.html">
327 to Secondary Sources</a></p>
328 </font>
329
330</body>
331
332</html><!-- text below generated by server. PLEASE REMOVE --><!-- Counter/Statistics data collection code --><script language="JavaScript" src="http://hostingprod.com/js_source/geov2.js"></script><script language="javascript">geovisit();</script><noscript><img src="http://visit.webhosting.yahoo.com/visit.gif?us1108082621" alt="setstats" border="0" width="1" height="1"></noscript>
333<IMG SRC="http://geo.yahoo.com/serv?s=76001524&t=1108082621" ALT=1 WIDTH=1 HEIGHT=1>
Note: See TracBrowser for help on using the repository browser.