1 | <html>
|
---|
2 |
|
---|
3 | <head>
|
---|
4 | <meta name="content" content="biography of Queen Elizabeth I (1533-1603) by Edward Spencer Beesly, 1892">
|
---|
5 | <meta name="page_topic" content="biography of Queen Elizabeth I (1533-1603) by Edward Spencer Beesly, 1892">
|
---|
6 | <meta name="author" content="Marilee Mongello">
|
---|
7 | <meta name="GENERATOR" content="Microsoft FrontPage 5.0">
|
---|
8 | <meta name="ProgId" content="FrontPage.Editor.Document">
|
---|
9 | <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=windows-1252">
|
---|
10 | <meta http-equiv="Content-Language" content="en-us">
|
---|
11 | <title>Secondary Sources: Queen Elizabeth by Edward Spencer Beesly, 1892:
|
---|
12 | Chapter XI</title>
|
---|
13 | <style>
|
---|
14 | </style>
|
---|
15 | <style fprolloverstyle>A:hover {color: #0000FF; font-weight: bold}
|
---|
16 | .3text {font-size: 12 px;}
|
---|
17 | </style>
|
---|
18 | </head>
|
---|
19 |
|
---|
20 | <body link="#0000FF" vlink="#0000FF" alink="#0000FF">
|
---|
21 |
|
---|
22 | <table border="0" cellpadding="3" width="100%" height="667">
|
---|
23 | <tr>
|
---|
24 | <td width="25%" height="29"></td>
|
---|
25 | <td valign="top" width="50%" height="29"> </td>
|
---|
26 | <td width="25%" height="29"></td>
|
---|
27 | </tr>
|
---|
28 | <tr>
|
---|
29 | <td width="25%" height="3"></td>
|
---|
30 | <td width="50%" height="3"><font size="3"></font></td>
|
---|
31 | <td width="25%" height="3"></td>
|
---|
32 | </tr>
|
---|
33 | <tr>
|
---|
34 | <td width="25%" height="610"></td>
|
---|
35 | <td valign="top" width="50%" height="610">
|
---|
36 | <p align="center"><b><font size="7">Queen Elizabeth<br></font></b>
|
---|
37 | <font size="4">by Edward Spencer Beesly, 1892</font></p>
|
---|
38 | <p align="center">
|
---|
39 | <img border="2" src="eliz1-ermine.jpg" width="400" height="478" alt="'The Ermine Portrait' of Elizabeth I, c1585, by Nicholas Hilliard"><p align="center">
|
---|
40 | <i><font size="2">'The Ermine Portrait' of Elizabeth I, c1585, by Nicholas
|
---|
41 | Hilliard;<br>from the <a href="http://www.marileecody.com/eliz1-images.html">Portraits of Queen Elizabeth I</a> website</font></i></td>
|
---|
42 | <td width="25%" height="610"></td>
|
---|
43 | </tr>
|
---|
44 | </table>
|
---|
45 | <blockquote>
|
---|
46 | <blockquote>
|
---|
47 | <font style="font-family: Times New Roman"></font>
|
---|
48 | <font style="font-family: Times New Roman"></font>
|
---|
49 | <font style="font-family: Times New Roman"></font>
|
---|
50 | <font style="font-family: Times New Roman"></font>
|
---|
51 | <font style="font-family: Times New Roman"></font>
|
---|
52 | <font style="font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif">
|
---|
53 | <font style="font-family: Times New Roman">
|
---|
54 | <div align="left">
|
---|
55 | <b>CHAPTER XI</b><br>
|
---|
56 | <b>DOMESTIC AFFAIRS: 1588-1601</b></div>
|
---|
57 | <p align="left"><font size="3">IT was a boast of Elizabeth that when once
|
---|
58 | her servants were chosen she did not lightly displace them. Difference of
|
---|
59 | opinion from their mistress, or from one another, did not involve
|
---|
60 | resignation or dismissal, because, though they were free to speak their
|
---|
61 | minds, all had to carry out with fidelity and even zeal, whatever policy the
|
---|
62 | Queen prescribed. This condition they accepted; not only the astute and
|
---|
63 | compliant Burghley, but the more eager and opinionated Walsingham; and
|
---|
64 | therefore they had practically a life-tenure of office. Soon after the
|
---|
65 | Armada the first generation of them began to disappear. Bacon, Sussex, and
|
---|
66 | Bedford were already gone. Leicester died in 1588; his brother Warwick, and
|
---|
67 | Mildmay in 1589; Walsingham and Randolph in 1591; Hatton in 1592; Grey de
|
---|
68 | Wilton in 1593; Knollys and Hunsdon in 1596. Of the trusty servants with
|
---|
69 | whom she began her reign, Burghley alone remained. The leading men of the
|
---|
70 | new generation were Robert Cecil, the Treasurer's second son, trained to
|
---|
71 | business under his father's eye, and of qualities similar, though inferior;
|
---|
72 | Nottingham (formerly Howard of Effingham), a straightforward man of no great
|
---|
73 | ability, but acceptable to the Queen for his father's services and his own
|
---|
74 | (and not the less so for his fine presence); the accomplished Buckhurst; the
|
---|
75 | brilliant Raleigh; and, younger than the rest, Essex. The last was the son
|
---|
76 | of a man much favoured by Elizabeth. Leicester was his step-father, Knollys
|
---|
77 | his grandfather, Hunsdon his great-uncle, Walsingham his father-in-law,
|
---|
78 | Burghley his guardian. Ardent, impulsive, presumptuous, a warm friend, a
|
---|
79 | rancorous enemy, profuse in expense, lawless in his amours, jealous of his
|
---|
80 | equals, brooking no superior, impatient of all rule or order that delayed
|
---|
81 | him from leaping at once to the highest place,--he was possessed with a most
|
---|
82 | exaggerated notion of his own capacity, which appears to have been only
|
---|
83 | moderate. As the ward of Burghley he had been much in the company of his
|
---|
84 | future enemy, Robert Cecil, whose sly prim ways were most unlike his own.
|
---|
85 | The contrast did him no harm with the public, to whom the younger man was a
|
---|
86 | Tom Jones and the elder a Blifil. Two vastly abler men, Francis Bacon and
|
---|
87 | Raleigh, less advantageously placed, but unhampered with any scruples, were
|
---|
88 | busily trying to profit by the all-pervading animosity of Cecil and Essex.
|
---|
89 | </font></p>
|
---|
90 | <p align="left"><font size="3">Belonging, as Essex did by his connections,
|
---|
91 | to the inner circle who stood closest to Elizabeth, it was natural that she
|
---|
92 | should take an interest in him, and give him opportunities for turning his
|
---|
93 | showy qualities to account. In 1586 he was sent to the Low Countries as
|
---|
94 | general of cavalry under his step-father, Leicester. He distinguished
|
---|
95 | himself by his fiery valour in the expeditions to Spain, and as commander of
|
---|
96 | the English army in France, though he does not seem to have had any real
|
---|
97 | military talent. But Elizabeth's regard for him was soon shaken by his
|
---|
98 | presumptuous and unruly behaviour. When he fought a duel with Sir Charles
|
---|
99 | Blount because she had conferred some favour on the latter, she swore "by
|
---|
100 | God's death it were fitting some one should take him down and teach him
|
---|
101 | better manners, or there were no rule with him." He displeased her by his
|
---|
102 | quarrels with Cecil and Effingham, and his discontented grumbling. She was
|
---|
103 | highly dissatisfied with his management of the Azores expedition in 1597. In
|
---|
104 | July 1598, at a meeting of the Council, she was provoked by his insolence to
|
---|
105 | strike him; and though after three months he obtained his pardon, he never
|
---|
106 | regained her favour. </font></p>
|
---|
107 | <p align="left"><font size="3">It was at this time that Burghley died (4
|
---|
108 | August), in his seventy-eighth year. Elizabeth, though she could call him "a
|
---|
109 | froward old fool" about a trifling matter ( March 1596), could not but feel
|
---|
110 | that much was changed when she lost the able and faithful servant who had
|
---|
111 | worked with her for forty years. "She seemeth to take it very grievously,
|
---|
112 | shedding of tears and separating herself from all company." Buckhurst was
|
---|
113 | the new Treasurer. </font></p>
|
---|
114 | <p align="left"><font size="3">Essex had for some time cast his eyes on
|
---|
115 | Ireland as a field where glory and power might be won. There can be little
|
---|
116 | doubt that he was already speculating on the advantage that the possession
|
---|
117 | of an army might give him in any difficulty with his rivals or with the
|
---|
118 | Queen herself. Cecil perfidiously advocated his appointment to a post which
|
---|
119 | had been the grave of so many reputations. The Queen at length consented,
|
---|
120 | though reluctantly. Essex was a popular favourite. He had managed--it is not
|
---|
121 | very clear how--to win the confidence of both Puritans and Papists. The
|
---|
122 | general belief was that, for the first time since she had mounted the
|
---|
123 | throne, Elizabeth was afraid of one of her subjects. </font></p>
|
---|
124 | <p align="left"><font size="3">During the whole of the reign Ireland had
|
---|
125 | been a cause of trouble and anxiety. Elizabeth's treatment of that unhappy
|
---|
126 | country was not more creditable or successful than that of other English
|
---|
127 | statesmen before and after her. There was the same absence of any systematic
|
---|
128 | policy steadily carried out, the same wearisome and disreputable alternation
|
---|
129 | between bursts of savage repression and intervals of pusillanimity,
|
---|
130 | concession, and neglect. In the competition of the various departments of
|
---|
131 | the public service for attention and expenditure, Ireland generally came
|
---|
132 | last. All other needs had to be served first whether at home or abroad.
|
---|
133 | </font></p>
|
---|
134 | <p align="left"><font size="3">In the early years of the reign the chief
|
---|
135 | trouble lay in Ulster, then the most purely Celtic part of Ireland, and
|
---|
136 | practically retouched by English conquest. Twice, in her weariness of the
|
---|
137 | struggle with Shan O'Neill, Elizabeth conceded to him something like a
|
---|
138 | subkingship of Ulster in return for his nominal submission. In the end he
|
---|
139 | was beaten, and his head was fixed on the walls of Dublin Castle (1566). But
|
---|
140 | nothing further was done to anglicise Ulster. During the attempt of the
|
---|
141 | Devonshire adventurers to colonise South Munster (1569-71), and the
|
---|
142 | consequent rebellion, the northern province remained an unconcerned
|
---|
143 | spectator. Nor did it join in the great Desmond rising (1579-83), which,
|
---|
144 | with the insurrection of the Catholic lords of the Pale and the landing of
|
---|
145 | the Pope's Italians at Smerwick, was the Irish branch of the threefold
|
---|
146 | attack on Elizabeth directed by Gregory XIII. The attempt of the elder Essex
|
---|
147 | to colonise Antrim (1573-75) was a disastrous failure, and Ulster still
|
---|
148 | remained practically independent of the Dublin Government. </font></p>
|
---|
149 | <p align="left"><font size="3">The most successful Deputy of the reign was
|
---|
150 | Perrot (1584-87), a valiant soldier and strict ruler, who, after long
|
---|
151 | experience in the Irish wars, had come to the conclusion that what Ireland
|
---|
152 | most wanted was justice. The native chiefs, released from the constant dread
|
---|
153 | of spoliation, and finding that English encroachment was repressed as
|
---|
154 | inflexibly as Irish disorder, became quiet and friendly. But this system did
|
---|
155 | not suit the dominant race. The Deputy was accused to the Queen of seeking
|
---|
156 | to betray the country to the Irish and the Spaniard. Recalled, and put upon
|
---|
157 | his trial for treason, he was found guilty on suborned evidence, and
|
---|
158 | sentenced to death. It is usually said that his real offence was some
|
---|
159 | disrespectful language about the Queen, which he confessed. But it seems
|
---|
160 | that she forbore to take his life precisely because she would not have it
|
---|
161 | thought that she was influenced by personal resentment. </font></p>
|
---|
162 | <p align="left"><font size="3">His successor, Fitzwilliam, was a Deputy of
|
---|
163 | the old sort--greedy, violent, careless of consequences, and always acting
|
---|
164 | on the principle that, as against an Englishman, a Celt had no rights. The
|
---|
165 | execution of MacMahon in Monaghan, and the confiscation of his lands on a
|
---|
166 | trivial pretext, alarmed the North. Ulster had not been bled white like the
|
---|
167 | rest of Ireland. The O'Neills had a nephew of their old hero Shan for their
|
---|
168 | chief, who had been brought up at the English Court and made Earl of Tyrone
|
---|
169 | by Elizabeth. An educated and remarkably able man, he had none of his
|
---|
170 | uncle's illusions. He clung to his ancestral rights and dignity, but he
|
---|
171 | hoped to preserve them by zealously discharging his obligations as a vassal
|
---|
172 | of the Queen. He served in the war against Desmond, and exerted himself to
|
---|
173 | maintain order in Ulster. But he had no mind to sink into the position of a
|
---|
174 | mere dignified land-owner like the English nobles; nor indeed, under such a
|
---|
175 | Deputy as Fitzwilliam, was he likely to preserve even his lands if he lost
|
---|
176 | his power. Rather than that, he determined to enter into what he knew was a
|
---|
177 | most unequal struggle, on the off-chance of pulling through by help from
|
---|
178 | Spain. It is clear that he was driven into rebellion against his
|
---|
179 | inclination. But when he had once drawn the sword he maintained the struggle
|
---|
180 | against one Deputy after another with wonderful tenacity and resource. For
|
---|
181 | the first time in Irish history, the rebel forces were disciplined and armed
|
---|
182 | like those of the crown, and stood up to them in equal numbers on equal
|
---|
183 | terms. At length, in August 1598, Tyrone inflicted upon Sir Henry Bagnall
|
---|
184 | near Armagh the severest defeat that the English had ever suffered in
|
---|
185 | Ireland; slaying 1500 of his men, and capturing all his artillery and
|
---|
186 | baggage. Insurrections at once broke out all over Ireland. </font></p>
|
---|
187 | <p align="left"><font size="3">This was the situation with which Essex
|
---|
188 | undertook to deal. He had loudly blamed other Deputies for not vigorously
|
---|
189 | attacking Tyrone in his own country. Vigour was the one military quality
|
---|
190 | which he himself possessed. He went with the title of Lieutenant and
|
---|
191 | Governor-General, and with extraordinary powers, at the head of 21,000
|
---|
192 | men--such an army as had never been sent to Ireland (April 1599). The Queen,
|
---|
193 | who trembled at the expense, and did not wish to see any of her nobles,
|
---|
194 | least of all Essex, permanently established in a great military command,
|
---|
195 | enjoined him to push at once into Ulster, as he had himself proposed, and
|
---|
196 | finish the war. Instead of doing this, he went south into districts that had
|
---|
197 | been depopulated and desolated by the savage warfare of the last thirty
|
---|
198 | years. Even here he met with discreditable reverses. When he got back to
|
---|
199 | Dublin (July) his army was reduced by disease and desertion to less than
|
---|
200 | 5000 men. Disregarding the Queen's express prohibition, he made his friend
|
---|
201 | Southampton General of horse. When she censured his bad management, he
|
---|
202 | replied with impertinent complaints about the favour she was showing to
|
---|
203 | Cecil, Raleigh, and Cobham, and began to consult with his friends about
|
---|
204 | carrying selected troops over to England to remove them. Rumours of his
|
---|
205 | intention to return reached the Queen. "We do charge you," she wrote, "as
|
---|
206 | you tender our pleasure, that you adventure not to come out of that
|
---|
207 | kingdom." He declared that he could not invade Ulster without
|
---|
208 | reinforcements. They were sent, and at length he marched into Louth
|
---|
209 | (September). There he was met by Tyrone, who, in an interview, completely
|
---|
210 | twisted him round his finger, and obtained a cessation of arms and the
|
---|
211 | promise of concessions amounting to what would now be called Home Rule. A
|
---|
212 | few days later, on receipt of an angry letter from the Queen forbidding him
|
---|
213 | to grant any terms without her permission, he deserted his post and hurried
|
---|
214 | to England. The first notice Elizabeth received of this astounding piece of
|
---|
215 | insubordination was his still more astounding incursion into her bedroom,
|
---|
216 | all muddy from his ride, before she was completely dressed (28 September
|
---|
217 | 1599). </font></p>
|
---|
218 | <p align="left"><font size="3">Elizabeth seems to have been so much taken
|
---|
219 | aback by the Earl's unparalleled presumption, that she did not blaze out as
|
---|
220 | might have been expected. She gave him audience an hour or two later, and
|
---|
221 | heard what he had to say. Probably he adopted an injured tone as usual, and
|
---|
222 | inveighed against "that knave Raleigh" and "that sycophant Cobham." But his
|
---|
223 | insubordination had been gross, and no talking could make it anything else.
|
---|
224 | It was more dangerous than Leicester's disobedience in 1586, because it came
|
---|
225 | from a vastly more dangerous person. The same afternoon the Queen referred
|
---|
226 | the matter to the Council. Essex was put under arrest, and never saw her
|
---|
227 | again. The more she reflected, the more indignant and alarmed she became.
|
---|
228 | "By God's son," she said to Harington, "I am no Queen; this man is above
|
---|
229 | me." After a delay of nine months, occasioned by his illness, the fallen
|
---|
230 | favourite was brought before a special Commission on the charge of contempt
|
---|
231 | and disobedience, and sentenced to be suspended from his offices and
|
---|
232 | confined to his house during the Queen's pleasure (June 1600). In a few
|
---|
233 | weeks he was released from arrest, but he could not obtain permission to
|
---|
234 | appear at court, though he implored it in most abject letters. </font></p>
|
---|
235 | <p align="left"><font size="3">There are persons who consider themselves to
|
---|
236 | be intolerably wronged and persecuted if they cannot have precedence and
|
---|
237 | power over their fellow-citizens. Essex was such a person. Instead of being
|
---|
238 | thankful that he had escaped the punishment which under most sovereigns he
|
---|
239 | would have suffered, he entered into criminal plots for coercing, if not
|
---|
240 | overthrowing, the Queen. He urged the Scotch King to enforce the recognition
|
---|
241 | of his title by arms. He tried to persuade Mountjoy, his successor in
|
---|
242 | Ireland, to carry his army to Scotland to co-operate with James. These
|
---|
243 | intrigues were not known to the Government. But it did not escape
|
---|
244 | observation that he was collecting men of the sword in the neighbourhood of
|
---|
245 | his house; that he was holding consultations with suspected nobles and
|
---|
246 | gentlemen (some of whom were afterwards engaged in the Gunpowder Plot); that
|
---|
247 | the Puritan clergy were preaching and praying for his cause; and that there
|
---|
248 | was a certain ferment in the city. Essex was therefore summoned to attend
|
---|
249 | before the Council. Instead of obeying, he flew to arms, with Lords
|
---|
250 | Southampton, Rutland, Sandys, Cromwell, and Monteagle, and about 300
|
---|
251 | gentlemen. But the citizens of London did not respond to his appeal, and the
|
---|
252 | insurrection was easily suppressed, less than a dozen persons being slain on
|
---|
253 | both sides (8 February 1601). A more senseless and profligate attempt to
|
---|
254 | overthrow a good government it would be difficult to find in history. It was
|
---|
255 | not dignified by any semblance of principle, and it would sufficiently stamp
|
---|
256 | the character of its author, even if it stood alone as an evidence of his
|
---|
257 | vanity, egotism, and want of common sense. </font></p>
|
---|
258 | <p align="left"><font size="3">The trial and execution of the principal
|
---|
259 | malefactor followed as a matter of course and without delay (February 25).
|
---|
260 | It would have been scandalous to spare him. Elizabeth had once been fond of
|
---|
261 | him, and had no reason to be ashamed of it. To talk of her "passion" and her
|
---|
262 | "amorous inclination," as Hume and others have done, is revolting and
|
---|
263 | malignant nonsense. It is creditable to old age when it can take pleasure in
|
---|
264 | the unfolding of bright and promising youth. But royal favour was not good
|
---|
265 | for such a man as Essex. It developed the worst features in his showy but
|
---|
266 | faulty character. As he steadily deteriorated, her regard cooled; but so
|
---|
267 | much of it remained that she tried to amend him by chastisement, "ad
|
---|
268 | correctionem," as she said, "non ad ruinam." She had long before warned him
|
---|
269 | that, though she had put up with much disrespect to her person, he must not
|
---|
270 | touch her sceptre, or he would be dealt with according to the law of
|
---|
271 | England. She was as good as her word, and, though the memory of it was
|
---|
272 | painful to her, there is not the smallest evidence that she ever repented of
|
---|
273 | having allowed the law to take its course. Only three of the accomplices of
|
---|
274 | Essex were punished capitally. The five peers, none of them powerful or
|
---|
275 | formidable, experienced Elizabeth's accustomed clemency. </font></p>
|
---|
276 | <p align="left"><font size="3">It has been suggested by an admirer of Essex
|
---|
277 | that he failed in Ireland because his "sensitively attuned nature" shrank
|
---|
278 | from the systematic desolation and starvation afterwards employed by his
|
---|
279 | successor. No evidence is offered for this suggestion. In a letter to the
|
---|
280 | Queen (25 June 1599) he advocates "burning and spoiling the country <i>in
|
---|
281 | all places</i>," which method "shall starve the rebels in one year." This
|
---|
282 | course Mountjoy carried out. With means far inferior to those of Essex, and
|
---|
283 | notwithstanding the landing of 3000 Spaniards at Kinsale (September 1601),
|
---|
284 | he was the first Englishman who completely subdued Ireland. Tyrone
|
---|
285 | surrendered a few days before the Queen's death. </font></p>
|
---|
286 | <p align="left"><font size="3">Little has been said in these pages about
|
---|
287 | parliamentary proceedings. The real history of the reign does not lie there.
|
---|
288 | The country was governed wholly by the Queen, with the advice of her
|
---|
289 | Council, and not at all by Parliament. In the forty-five years of her reign
|
---|
290 | there were only thirteen sessions of Parliament. The functions of Parliament
|
---|
291 | were to vote grants of money when the ordinary revenues of the crown were
|
---|
292 | insufficient, and to make laws. Its right in these matters was unquestioned.
|
---|
293 | If the Queen had never wanted subsidies or penal laws against her political
|
---|
294 | and religious opponents (of other laws she often said there were more than
|
---|
295 | enough already), it would never have been summoned at all; nor is there any
|
---|
296 | reason to suppose that the country would have complained as long as it was
|
---|
297 | governed with prudence and success. In fact, to do without Parliaments was
|
---|
298 | distinctly popular, because it meant doing without subsidies. </font></p>
|
---|
299 | <p align="left"><font size="3">In the thirty years preceding the Armada--the
|
---|
300 | sessions of Parliament being nine--Elizabeth applied for only eight
|
---|
301 | subsidies, and of one of them a portion was remitted. By her economy she not
|
---|
302 | only defrayed the expenses of government out of the ordinary revenue, which,
|
---|
303 | at the end of the reign was about £300,000 a year, but paid off old debts.
|
---|
304 | It was not till the twenty-fourth year of her reign that she discharged the
|
---|
305 | last of her father's debts, up to which time she had been paying interest on
|
---|
306 | it. Subsequently she even accumulated a small reserve, which, as she told
|
---|
307 | Parliament, was a most necessary thing if she was not to be driven to borrow
|
---|
308 | on sudden emergency. But this reserve vanished immediately she became
|
---|
309 | involved in the great war with Spain; and during the last fifteen years of
|
---|
310 | her life, although she received twelve subsidies, she was always in
|
---|
311 | difficulty for money. She had to sell crown lands to the value of £372,000.
|
---|
312 | Parliament, which had voted the usual single subsidies without complaint,
|
---|
313 | grumbled and pretended poverty when she asked for three and even four.
|
---|
314 | Bacon's famous outburst (1593) about gentlemen having to sell their plate
|
---|
315 | and farmers their brass pots to pay the tax, was a piece of claptrap. The
|
---|
316 | nation was, relatively to former times, rolling in wealth. But the old
|
---|
317 | belief had still considerable strength--that government being the affair of
|
---|
318 | the King, not of his subjects, he should provide for its expenses out of his
|
---|
319 | hereditary income, just as they paid their private expenses out of their
|
---|
320 | private incomes; that he had no more claim to dip into their pockets than
|
---|
321 | they had to dip into his; and that a subsidy, as its name imports, was an
|
---|
322 | occasional and extraordinary assistance furnished as a matter not of duty
|
---|
323 | but of good-will. </font></p>
|
---|
324 | <p align="left"><font size="3">This might have been healthy doctrine when
|
---|
325 | kings were campaigning on the Continent for personal or dynastic objects. It
|
---|
326 | was out of place when a large expenditure was indispensable for the
|
---|
327 | interests and safety of the country. The grumbling, therefore, about
|
---|
328 | taxation towards the end of the reign was unreasonable and discreditable to
|
---|
329 | the grumblers. The Queen met them with her usual good sense. She explained
|
---|
330 | to them--though, as she correctly said, she was under no constitutional
|
---|
331 | obligation to do so--how the money went, what she had spent on the Spanish
|
---|
332 | war, on Ireland, and in loans to the Dutch and the French King. The plea was
|
---|
333 | unanswerable. Her private expenditure was on a very modest scale. In
|
---|
334 | particular she had never indulged in that besetting and costly sin of
|
---|
335 | princes, palace-building; and this at a time when the noble mansions which
|
---|
336 | still testify to the wealth of the England of that day were rising in every
|
---|
337 | county. Her only extravagance was dress. Some have carped at her collection
|
---|
338 | of jewelry. But jewels, like the silver balustrades of Frederick William I.,
|
---|
339 | were a mode of hoarding, and in her later years she reconverted jewels into
|
---|
340 | money to meet the expenses of the State. Modern writers, who so airily blame
|
---|
341 | her for not subsidising more liberally her Scotch, Dutch, and French allies,
|
---|
342 | would find it difficult, if they condescended to particulars, to explain how
|
---|
343 | she was able to give them as much money as she did. </font></p>
|
---|
344 | <p align="left"><font size="3">It is common to make much of the debate on
|
---|
345 | monopolies in the last Parliament of Elizabeth (1601), as showing the rise
|
---|
346 | of a spirit of resistance to the royal prerogative. I do not think that the
|
---|
347 | report of that debate would convey such an impression to any one reading it
|
---|
348 | without preconceived views. None of the speakers contested the prerogative.
|
---|
349 | They only complained that it was being exercised in a way prejudicial to the
|
---|
350 | public interest. If the monopolies had been unimportant, or if the patentees
|
---|
351 | had used their privilege less greedily, there would evidently have been no
|
---|
352 | complaint as to the principle involved. No course of action was decided on,
|
---|
353 | because the Queen intervened by a message in which she stated that she had
|
---|
354 | not been aware of the abuses prevailing, that she was as indignant at them
|
---|
355 | as Parliament could be, and that she would put a stop, not to monopolies,
|
---|
356 | but to such as were injurious. With this message the House of Commons was
|
---|
357 | more than satisfied. As a matter of fact monopolies went on till dealt with
|
---|
358 | by the declaratory statute in the twenty-first year of James I. </font></p>
|
---|
359 | <p align="left"><font size="3">If the last Tudor handed down the English
|
---|
360 | Constitution to the first Stuart as she had received it from her
|
---|
361 | predecessors, unchanged either in theory or practice, it was far otherwise
|
---|
362 | with the English Church. There are two conflicting views as to the
|
---|
363 | historical position of the Church in this country. According to one it was,
|
---|
364 | all through the Middle Age, National as well as Catholic. The changes which
|
---|
365 | took place at the Reformation made no difference in that respect, and
|
---|
366 | involved no break in its continuity. It is not a Protestant Church. It is
|
---|
367 | still National and still Catholic, resting on precisely the same
|
---|
368 | foundations, and existing by the same title as it did in the days of Dunstan
|
---|
369 | and Becket. According to the other view, the epithets National and Catholic
|
---|
370 | are contradictory. A Church which undergoes radical changes of government,
|
---|
371 | worship, and doctrine is no longer the same Church but a new one, and must
|
---|
372 | be held to have been established by the authority which prescribed these
|
---|
373 | changes, which, in this case, was the Queen and Parliament. The word
|
---|
374 | "Protestant" was avoided in its formularies to make conformity easier for
|
---|
375 | Catholics; but it is a Protestant Church all the same. Whichever of these
|
---|
376 | views is nearer to the truth, it cannot be denied that, by the legislation
|
---|
377 | of Elizabeth the English Church became--what it was not in the Middle Age--a
|
---|
378 | spiritual organisation entirely dependent on the State. This it remains
|
---|
379 | still; the supremacy having been virtually transferred from the crown to
|
---|
380 | Parliament in the next century. I shall not venture to inquire how far this
|
---|
381 | condition of dependence has affected its ability and inclination to perform
|
---|
382 | the part of a true spiritual power. It is enough to say that no act of will
|
---|
383 | on the part of any English statesman has had such important and lasting
|
---|
384 | consequences, for good or for evil, as the decision of Elizabeth to make the
|
---|
385 | Church of England what it is. </font></p>
|
---|
386 | <p align="left"><font size="3">We have seen that the government and worship
|
---|
387 | of the Church were established by <i>Act of Parliament in 1559</i>, and its
|
---|
388 | doctrines in 1571. But when once Elizabeth had placed her ecclesiastical
|
---|
389 | powers beyond dispute, by obtaining statutory sanction for them, she allowed
|
---|
390 | no further interference by Parliament. All its attempts, even at mere
|
---|
391 | discussion of ecclesiastical matters, she peremptorily suppressed. She
|
---|
392 | supplied any further legislation that was needed by virtue of her supremacy,
|
---|
393 | and she exercised her ecclesiastical government by the Court of High
|
---|
394 | Commission. The new Anglican model was acquiesced in by the majority of the
|
---|
395 | nation. But it had, at first, no hearty support except from the Government.
|
---|
396 | The earnest religionists were either Catholics or Puritans. The object of
|
---|
397 | Elizabeth was to compel these two extreme parties to outward conformity of
|
---|
398 | worship. What their real beliefs were she did not care. </font></p>
|
---|
399 | <p align="left"><font size="3">The large majority of the Catholics showed a
|
---|
400 | loyal and patriotic spirit at the time of the Armada. But they were not
|
---|
401 | treated with confidence by the Government. Great numbers of them were
|
---|
402 | imprisoned or confined in the houses of Protestant gentlemen, by way of
|
---|
403 | precaution, when the Armada was approaching. No Catholic, I believe, was
|
---|
404 | intrusted with any command either by land or sea; and after the danger was
|
---|
405 | over, the persecution, in all its forms, became sharper than ever. There was
|
---|
406 | the less reason for this, inasmuch as it was no secret that the secular
|
---|
407 | priests and the great majority of the English Catholics had become bitterly
|
---|
408 | hostile to the small Jesuitical faction whose treasonable conspiracies had
|
---|
409 | brought so much trouble on their loyal co-religionists. </font></p>
|
---|
410 | <p align="left"><font size="3">The term "Puritan" is used loosely, though
|
---|
411 | conveniently, to designate several shades of belief, By far the larger
|
---|
412 | number of those to whom it is applied were, and meant to remain, members of
|
---|
413 | the Established Church. They objected to certain ceremonies and vestments.
|
---|
414 | They hoped to procure the abolition of these, and, in the meantime, evaded
|
---|
415 | them when they could. They were what would now be called the Evangelical or
|
---|
416 | Low Church party. They held Calvin's distinctive doctrines on
|
---|
417 | predestination, as indeed did most of the bishops; but though preferring his
|
---|
418 | Presbyterian organisation, or something like it, they did not treat it as
|
---|
419 | essential. They were broadly distinguished from the Brownists or
|
---|
420 | Independents, then an insignificant minority, who held each congregation to
|
---|
421 | be a church, and therefore protested against the establishment of any
|
---|
422 | national church. </font></p>
|
---|
423 | <p align="left"><font size="3">Though Elizabeth persecuted the Catholics
|
---|
424 | with a severity steadily increasing in proportion as they became less
|
---|
425 | numerous and formidable, she remained to the last anxious to make conformity
|
---|
426 | easy for them. This was her reason for so obstinately refusing the
|
---|
427 | concessions in the matter of ritual and vestments-trifling as they appear to
|
---|
428 | the modern mind--which would have satisfied almost the whole of the Puritan
|
---|
429 | party. This policy (for policy it assuredly was rather than conviction),
|
---|
430 | which drove the most earnest Protestants into an attitude of opposition
|
---|
431 | destined in the next two reigns to have such serious consequences, has been
|
---|
432 | severely censured. But there can be no question that it did answer the
|
---|
433 | purpose she had in view, which for the moment was most important. It did
|
---|
434 | induce great numbers of Catholics to conform. She avoided a civil war in her
|
---|
435 | own time between Catholics and Anglicans at the price of a civil war later
|
---|
436 | on between Anglicans and Puritans. Looking at the great drama as a whole,
|
---|
437 | perhaps the Puritans of the Great Rebellion might congratulate themselves on
|
---|
438 | the part that Elizabeth chose to play in its earlier acts. It cannot be
|
---|
439 | doubted that a civil war in the sixteenth century between Catholics and
|
---|
440 | Protestants would have been waged with far more ferocity than was displayed
|
---|
441 | by either Cavaliers or Roundheads, and would have been attended with the
|
---|
442 | horrors of foreign invasion. To conciliate the earnest religionists on both
|
---|
443 | sides was impossible. Elizabeth chose the <i>via media</i>, and the
|
---|
444 | successful equilibrium which she maintained during nearly half a century
|
---|
445 | proves that she hit upon what in her own day was the true centre of gravity.
|
---|
446 | </font></p>
|
---|
447 | <p align="left"><font size="3">But while doing justice to Elizabeth's
|
---|
448 | insight and prudence, we may not excuse her extreme severity to the
|
---|
449 | nonconformists of either party. It was not necessary. It seems to have been
|
---|
450 | even impolitic. It arose from her arbitrary temper--from a quality, that is
|
---|
451 | to say, valuable in a ruler, but apt, in great rulers, to be somewhat in
|
---|
452 | excess. I have condemned her persecution of the Catholics. Her persecution
|
---|
453 | of the Protestant nonconformists was marked by even greater injustice.
|
---|
454 | Against the Catholics it might at least be urged that their opinions
|
---|
455 | logically led to disloyalty. But the Independents, Barrow, Greenwood, and
|
---|
456 | Penry, were indisputably loyal men. They were put to death nominally for
|
---|
457 | spreading writings which, contrary to common sense, were held to be
|
---|
458 | seditious, but really for their religious opinions, which, in the case of
|
---|
459 | the first two, were extracted from them by the interrogatories of Archbishop
|
---|
460 | Whitgift, an Inquisitor as strenuous and merciless as Torquemada. Some of
|
---|
461 | the Council, especially Burghley and Knollys, were strongly opposed to
|
---|
462 | Whitgift's proceedings. It must therefore be assumed that he had the Queen's
|
---|
463 | personal approval. She had committed herself to a struggle with intrepid and
|
---|
464 | obstinate men. The crowded gaols were a visible demonstration that she could
|
---|
465 | not compel them to submit; and to hang them all was out of the question. An
|
---|
466 | Act was therefore passed in 1593, by which those who would not promise to
|
---|
467 | attend church were to be banished the country. Thus most of the Independents
|
---|
468 | were at last got rid of. The non-separatist Puritans, who aimed at less
|
---|
469 | radical changes, and hoped to effect them, if not under their present
|
---|
470 | sovereign, yet under her successor, kept on the windy side of the law,
|
---|
471 | attending church once a month, and not entering till the service was nearly
|
---|
472 | over. Thus, at the end of her reign, Elizabeth perhaps flattered herself
|
---|
473 | that she was within measurable distance of religious uniformity. </font></p>
|
---|
474 | </font>
|
---|
475 | <hr>
|
---|
476 | <p align="left"><font style="font-family: Times New Roman" size="2">From <i>
|
---|
477 | Queen Elizabeth</i> by Edward Spencer Beesly. Published in London by
|
---|
478 | Macmillan and Co., 1892.</font></p>
|
---|
479 | </font>
|
---|
480 | <font face="Times New Roman" size="2">
|
---|
481 | </blockquote>
|
---|
482 | </blockquote>
|
---|
483 |
|
---|
484 | <p align="center">
|
---|
485 | <a href="beeslychaptertwelve.html">to Chapter
|
---|
486 | XII: Last Years and Death: 1601-1603</a></p>
|
---|
487 | <p align="center">
|
---|
488 | <a href="monarchs/eliz1.html">to the Queen
|
---|
489 | Elizabeth I website</a> /
|
---|
490 | <a href="relative/maryqos.html">to the Mary,
|
---|
491 | queen of Scots website</a></p>
|
---|
492 | <p align="center"><a href="secondary.html">
|
---|
493 | to Secondary Sources</a></p>
|
---|
494 | </font>
|
---|
495 |
|
---|
496 | </body>
|
---|
497 |
|
---|
498 | </html><!-- text below generated by server. PLEASE REMOVE --><!-- Counter/Statistics data collection code --><script language="JavaScript" src="http://hostingprod.com/js_source/geov2.js"></script><script language="javascript">geovisit();</script><noscript><img src="http://visit.webhosting.yahoo.com/visit.gif?us1108082629" alt="setstats" border="0" width="1" height="1"></noscript>
|
---|
499 | <IMG SRC="http://geo.yahoo.com/serv?s=76001524&t=1108082629" ALT=1 WIDTH=1 HEIGHT=1>
|
---|