source: other-projects/nightly-tasks/diffcol/trunk/gs3-model-collect/Tudor-Enhanced/import/englishhistory.net/tudor/citizens/cromwell.html@ 28145

Last change on this file since 28145 was 28145, checked in by ak19, 11 years ago

Committing the GS3 model collections for the tutorials originally built on Windows up to the 19th of July 2013, but re-built on Linux today. Enhanced-PDF not committed as its PDF to img conversion has issues.

  • Property svn:executable set to *
File size: 41.9 KB
Line 
1<!doctype html public "-//w3c//dtd html 4.0 transitional//en">
2<html>
3<head>
4 <meta http-equiv="Content-Type" content="text/html; charset=iso-8859-1">
5 <meta name="Author" content="Marilee Mongello">
6 <meta name="GENERATOR" content="Mozilla/4.61 [en] (Win98; I) [Netscape]">
7 <title>Tudor Citizens - Thomas Cromwell</title>
8</head>
9<body text="#000000" bgcolor="#FFFFFF" link="#006600" vlink="#006600" alink="#000000">
10
11<center><img SRC="cromwell.gif" ALT="Thomas Cromwell" height=59 width=313>
12<br>born c.1485 in Putney
13<br>executed 28 July 1540 in London
14<p><b><font size=+1>"A good household manager, but not fit to meddle in
15the affairs of kings."</font></b>
16<br><font size=-1>May 1538, Henry VIII describes Cromwell to the French
17ambassador</font></center>
18
19<p><img SRC="cromwell-small.jpg" ALT="portrait of Cromwell as the earl of Essex" BORDER=2 height=264 width=220 align=LEFT>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;
20Thomas Cromwell was as great a statesman as England has ever seen and,
21in his decade of power, permanently changed the course of English history.&nbsp;
22Unlike his mentor, Cardinal Wolsey, Cromwell was not a priest or a papist.&nbsp;
23He was a lawyer determined to impose his own character - methodical, detached,
24and calculating - upon government.
25<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Cromwell wanted government to be effective and efficient;
26to achieve this, he had to end the chaos of feudal privilege and ill-defined
27jurisdictions.&nbsp; He was blessed with a logical mind in an age sadly
28devoid of them.&nbsp; And unlike his royal master, he did not let his emotions
29interfere with his position.&nbsp; He was the ideal statesman for Tudor
30England and, just months after his execution in 1540, Henry VIII was bemoaning
31his loss.
32<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Cromwell was introduced to government service as
33a secretary for <a href="wolsey.html">Cardinal
34Wolsey</a>.&nbsp; His abilities won him the older man's respect and soon
35Cromwell was his most trusted servant and principal secretary.&nbsp; But
36Cromwell managed to distance himself from Wolsey immediately after the
37Cardinal fell from grace and soon had taken his place as Henry's most valuable
38advisor.&nbsp; Before entering Wolsey's service, Cromwell lived an adventurous
39life.&nbsp; His father had been a brewer and blacksmith known for permanent
40drunkenness and illegal activities.&nbsp; From this inauspicious beginning,
41his son went on to indulge his curiosity and practical nature by traveling
42through Europe.&nbsp; Over the course of several years, he was a soldier
43in Europe, a banker in Italy, clerk in the Netherlands, and a lawyer in
44London.&nbsp; Like so many ambitious men, he was in Wolsey's service in
45the mid-1520s.&nbsp; His most important work was the suppression of 29
46religious houses whose monies Wolsey used to endow colleges at Ipswich
47and Oxford.&nbsp; When Wolsey fell from grace in 1529, Cromwell was hurriedly
48elected burgess for Taunton so he could remain in government service.
49<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; There were striking similarities between the two
50men - both managed to remain favorites of the mercurial Henry VIII for
51years; both were despised by the older nobility who coveted their influence
52with the king; both sought to reform the creaky medieval bureaucracy of
53Tudor government; both were highly intelligent and well-versed in international
54affairs.&nbsp; And both, ultimately, fell from Henry's favor with spectacular
55speed.&nbsp; In the end, the king preferred to listen to the old nobility.
56<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; But Cromwell and Wolsey were also markedly different
57in many ways.&nbsp; Cromwell was the man responsible for the Henrician
58reformation while Wolsey fell because he served two masters, the king of
59England and the Pope.&nbsp; Though Henry had ejected Rome from his nation,
60he still practiced the Roman Catholic religion.&nbsp; The king's religious
61tendencies were never reformist and many historians have made the mistake
62of painting him as one of the first Protestant kings.&nbsp; Henry was never
63a Protestant and he wrote treatises vilifying Martin Luther for which he
64was titled 'Defender of the Faith' by the Pope.&nbsp; Rather, he was an
65opportunist who disliked papal authority and interference in his realm
66and wanted some of the vast wealth the English church possessed.&nbsp;
67For Henry, often desperately short of money, it was near-blasphemy for
68his subjects to pay taxes directly to Rome; he wanted the money for his
69government.&nbsp; He also wanted an annulment from a devoutly Catholic
70wife, Katharine of Aragon, and when the Pope, held hostage by the Holy
71Roman Emperor, refused to rule in his favor, he found it most expedient
72to simply disregard the papacy.&nbsp; But throughout it all, Henry was
73unaware of the forces he had unleashed when he declared himself head of
74the English church.&nbsp; Trained for the church as a child, he remained
75staunchly Catholic for his entire life though the Catholic church deemed
76him a heretic.
77<center>
78<p><b><u><font color="#000000">a discussion of the Henrician reformation</font></u></b></center>
79
80<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is important to remember that during Henry's reign,
81at least half of his subjects were under the age of eighteen.&nbsp; Henry's
82court swarmed with young people - pages, scullery maids, and the like.&nbsp;
83English culture celebrated youth; tournaments, hunts, glorious warfare
84were all the province of the young and strong.&nbsp; And while Henry was
85young, he joined these events with a gusto sadly lacking in his father
86or son.&nbsp; But time does not stop, not even for a despotic monarch determined
87to have his way in all things.&nbsp; During his 'great matter', Henry was
88in his thirties and changing from 'Bluff King Hal' into an overweight and
89balding hypochondriac.&nbsp; He had rid himself of Rome to gain wealth
90and a son.&nbsp; He gained both and, once he had, continually toyed with
91the idea of making peace with the pope.&nbsp; He didn't relish excommunication
92and it is likely that he persuaded himself that he wasn't disobeying Christ's
93vicar but rather the Emperor's puppet.
94<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; But he misjudged the mood of his people, particularly
95his nobles.&nbsp; Educated and by nature inquisitive and acquisitive, the
96new Protestant teachings intrigued them; they also sought the vast monastic
97lands which Henry planned to sell.&nbsp; This was the paradox of the Henrician
98reformation.&nbsp; It was motivated by greed and genuine religious turmoil.&nbsp;
99As time passed, the new generation of nobles were Protestant because it
100was expedient and philosophically appealing.&nbsp; And with each year,
101more Englishmen were born who were further and further away from the old
102days of Roman domination.&nbsp; Henry, in his forties, could remember the
103papist ways but, as the years passed, fewer and fewer of his subjects did.
104<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In terms of the practical effect the reformation
105had on everyday Englishmen, the situation is more difficult to gauge.&nbsp;
106Unlike the wealthy noblemen, they couldn't bid on the seized monastic properties.&nbsp;
107And in many towns and villages, the parish church was the community center,
108where births, weddings, and deaths were officiated over by a priest.&nbsp;
109But they undoubtedly enjoyed not paying their tax to Rome.&nbsp; Once again,
110a paradox emerged - an excommunicated nation which found itself torn between
111loyalty to the sovereign and loyalty to the papacy.&nbsp; Also, since Henry's
112marriage to Anne Boleyn could only be recognized if one accepted his annulment
113from Katharine - which in itself meant a rejection of papal authority -
114and it was treason to <i>not</i> recognize his marriage to Anne, then many
115people were swayed by the threat of execution.&nbsp; In other words, accept
116Henry's decisions or die.&nbsp; Of course, I cannot discuss all aspects
117of the reformation at this site; I recommend L.B. Smith's <i>Henry VIII</i>
118which studies Henry's own theological beliefs.
119<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; There was opposition to the reformation which probably
120had more to do with the attendant loss of independence in north England.&nbsp;
121In 1536, a northern uprising which came to be called the Pilgrimage of
122Grace, gathered over 40,000 men and marched through England.&nbsp; It eventually
123destroyed itself by internal division and lack of clear purpose but one
124of the rebels' demands was a warning for Cromwell - they want their king
125to be advised by <i>noble</i> councilors who understand the people's wishes,
126not common men like Cromwell.&nbsp; Henry was angry at their presumption
127- how dare his ignorant subjects rebel annd then tell him how to run the
128country! - but he was persuaded to show mercy and pardon those involved.&nbsp;
129And he continued to listen to Cromwell.
130<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The <a href="../primary.html">Pilgrimage
131of Grace</a> was largely motivated not by religious concerns but by Cromwell's
132determination to dissolve the monasteries and improve the royal tax collecting
133methods.&nbsp; For example, the movement began in Louth, in Lincolnshire,
134and began with the murder of two tax collectors, one of whom was hanged
135and the other sewn into a sack and thrown to a pack of hungry dogs!
136<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; So the common people might grumble somewhat but they
137were ultimately more influenced by practical matters.&nbsp; Had Henry's
138excommunication been followed by a terrible harvest or bad weather, it
139may have been otherwise.&nbsp; During his daughter Mary's reign, such signs
140were taken to mean God was angry with her for attempting to reinstate Catholicism.&nbsp;
141But not only did Henry enjoy good weather, he had a brilliant servant.&nbsp;
142Cromwell was the one who gave force to Henry's grand declarations.&nbsp;
143The king declared that Rome had no authority in England and Cromwell instituted
144the reforms which would make it so.&nbsp; The king declared that all monastic
145lands were forfeit and Cromwell set out to close the monasteries, assess
146their value, and sell them to the highest bidder.&nbsp; For a decade, this
147partnership worked marvelously.
148<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Also, Henry and Cromwell both recognized a fundamental
149truth of the English people; the government could do what it liked as long
150as traditional religious views were not upset too much.&nbsp; Certainly
151Henry did not upset his own.&nbsp; The name of the pope was omitted in
152their prayers but not much else.&nbsp; Henry's break with Rome was really
153a legal reformation rather than one of real religious content.&nbsp; England
154practiced Catholicism without a pope and, in his place, was their king.&nbsp;
155This situation suited Cromwell.&nbsp; Like many, he recognized that the
156Church had lost its way, remaining a ponderous medieval institution concerned
157with wealth and influence.&nbsp; But Europe was no longer medieval; countries
158were becoming nation-states, patriotic and immune to the cultural unity
159which Rome promoted.&nbsp; The pope envisioned a collection of nations
160joined beneath the cloak of Christendom with him at its head; but, particularly
161in xenophobic England, there were mutterings that the church was dominated
162by other nations.&nbsp; Also, the church claimed authority over its subjects;
163no priest or cleric could be tried by their sovereign nation.&nbsp; They
164would answer only to Rome.&nbsp; This problem had angered Henry II centuries
165before and resulted in Thomas Becket's murder.&nbsp; In Henry's time, it
166had grown worse.&nbsp; Also, as king, he believed himself ruler of <i>all</i>
167his subjects, priest and commoner alike.
168<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; One must also mention the corruption of the church,
169sadly evident to everyone.&nbsp; Certainly there were Godly men who struggled
170to enforce the tenets of their faith.&nbsp; But there were also bishops
171and cardinals more interested in business and finance than theology.&nbsp;
172The church preached that the surest path to heaven was through good works,
173particularly at a monastery or abbey, but every Englishmen knew that only
174the wealthy could afford to endow or board at them.&nbsp; Furthermore,
175an increasing number of churchmen were absent from their posts.&nbsp; Cardinal
176Wolsey embodied this avaricious streak; he was bishop, archbishop, abbot,
177and cardinal yet the affairs of state kept him from his duties.&nbsp; Instead
178of tending to his flock, he tended to his purse.&nbsp; He sired illegitimate
179children and collected nearly 50,000 pds a year from his vast holdings.
180<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Wolsey represented the church as it had become; certainly
181such abuses may not have turned most Englishmen from their faith.&nbsp;
182But when confronted with the forces of Protestantism, the church found
183precious few willing to die for their beliefs.&nbsp; After all, why would
184anyone die for a faith they didn't respect?&nbsp; When the king styled
185himself head of the church, many were perhaps relieved.&nbsp; Henry made
186no claim to a holy life, not like the churchman Wolsey; he also was shrewd
187enough to endow his monarchy with papal apparatus.&nbsp; From the 1530s
188on, the Tudor dynasty was even more divine and the machinery of state could
189enforce its divinity.
190<center>
191<p><b><u><font color="#000000">Cromwell's revolution in government</font></u></b></center>
192
193<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Cromwell's rise to power was extraordinary and occurred
194just when Henry needed a minister of great administrative imagination and
195genius, uninterested in the squabbles of his council and determined to
196empower the machinery of state.&nbsp; Cromwell entered royal service in
197early 1530 and, from then on, rose rapidly.&nbsp; In late 1530 he was sworn
198into the King's Council and, just a year later, began to attract unfavorable
199attention from Wolsey's old rivals.&nbsp; These were Stephen Gardiner,
200bishop of Winchester, Thomas Howard, duke of Norfolk, and Charles Brandon,
201duke of Suffolk.&nbsp; Gardiner had worked with Wolsey but, like Norfolk
202and Suffolk, viewed the Cardinal's fall as a chance to take his place.&nbsp;
203From 1529 to about 1533, they enjoyed the king's confidence even as Cromwell
204rose to overtake them all.&nbsp; His career progressed as follows:
205<br><b><font color="#990000">1531</font></b> - member of the privy council
206<br><b><font color="#990000">1532</font></b> - Master of Court of Wards
207and Master of Jewel House
208<br><b><font color="#990000">1533</font></b> - Chancellor of the Exchequer
209<br><font color="#990000"><b>1534</b> </font>- King's Secretary and Master
210of the Rolls
211<br><b><font color="#990000">1535</font></b> - Vicar-General
212<br><b><font color="#990000">1536</font></b> - Lord Privy Seal and Baron
213Cromwell of Oakham
214<br><b><font color="#990000">1537</font></b> - Knight of the Garter and
215Dean of Wells
216<br><b><font color="#990000">1539</font></b> - Lord Great Chamberlain
217<br><b><font color="#990000">1540</font></b> - created Earl of Essex
218<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; As the above list shows, Henry never forgot the fallen
219Wolsey.&nbsp; He had heaped honors upon him with extravagant generosity
220and had written to the pope recommending religious promotion.&nbsp; In
221the end, Henry believed himself betrayed.&nbsp; Not only had Wolsey accumulated
222obscene wealth, but he had grown arrogant and eventually treasonous.&nbsp;
223And so Cromwell, despite his years of diligence and genius, was eventually
224rewarded with an earldom but only a short time before his execution.
225<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; His influence upon the 1530s, one of the most influential
226and vital decades in English history, was enormous.&nbsp; One needs only
227to study the 1540s to realize how the loss of Cromwell affected Tudor government.&nbsp;
228He also came to power during Anne Boleyn's ascendancy.&nbsp; It was a symbolic
229changing of the guard - the old Katharine of Aragon thrust aside for the
230young, ambitious Anne Boleyn and Wolsey disgraced and replaced by his prot&eacute;g&eacute;
231Cromwell.&nbsp; Cromwell supported Anne until she, like Wolsey, became
232a liability.&nbsp; Among his immediate accomplishments were the following:
233<br><b><font color="#990000">1</font></b> - the dissolution of the monasteries
234and establishment of the royal supremacy
235<br><b><font color="#990000">2</font></b> - founded the ministries of Augmentations
236and First Fruits to handle income from the dissolution
237<br><b><font color="#990000">3</font></b> - founded the two courts of Wards
238and Surveyors which allowed more efficient taxation and leasing
239<br><b><font color="#990000">4 </font></b>- politically integrated the
240kingdom by extending sovereign authority into northern England, Wales &amp;
241Ireland (actions which angered the great feudal lords)
242<br><b><font color="#990000">5</font></b> - used the power of that relatively
243new invention, the printing-press and thus spearheaded the first propaganda
244campaign in English history.
245<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In the 1530s, he had instituted reforms of the English
246government which earned enmity from the nobility.&nbsp; Cromwell recognized
247the basic inefficiency of feudal government and, from it, struggled to
248create a more logical system.&nbsp; Instead of offices held solely because
249of birth, he wanted trained servants with expertise in their field.&nbsp;
250He built a bureaucracy of professionals outside the royal household.&nbsp;
251He began the first era of parliamentary control of England, using the institution
252to dissolve the monasteries which made up a quarter of all arable land
253and validate his other decisions.
254<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; From the above list, one will note that most of the
255'accomplishments' were motivated by financial need.&nbsp; Like his predecessors
256in government ministry, Cromwell needed to provide secure and regular income.&nbsp;
257This alone necessitated an assault on the church's wealth.&nbsp; Cromwell
258also developed a novel, and very unpopular idea - in the past, taxes were
259created to support warfare; in 1534, he developed a new tax.&nbsp; Its
260basis?&nbsp; The king's maintenance of peace.&nbsp; These measures did
261not help his reputation but, by 1547, had brought nearly 2,000,000 pds
262to Henry's treasury.&nbsp; Of course, Henry would use the entire windfall
263to finance his increasingly complicated foreign policy.&nbsp; At the time
264of Henry's death, all the wealth Cromwell had accumulated was gone and
265Edward VI was left with debased currency and massive debts.
266<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In 1534, however, Henry was prepared to reap the
267benefits of his new anti-clerical policies.&nbsp; He had appointed his
268friend Thomas Cranmer to the venerable and powerful position of Archbishop
269of Canterbury.&nbsp; Cranmer was like Cromwell in many ways - both owed
270their rise to prominence entirely to Henry's mercurial favor; both came
271from humble backgrounds; both were despised by the traditional nobility.&nbsp;
272Cranmer had come to Henry's attention by first suggesting a solution to
273the divorce problem - petition learned churchmen for their opinion, assuming
274they agreed with Henry.&nbsp; Like Cromwell, Cranmer benefited directly
275from the fall of Katharine of Aragon and the Imperial alliance and the
276rise of Anne Boleyn and her Norfolk relations.&nbsp; Henry's midlife crisis
277provided fertile ground for ambitious men.&nbsp; Cranmer and Cromwell liked
278one another and became friends, though Cranmer was careful to distance
279himself once Cromwell's ruin was assured.
280<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; In 1535, Henry appointed Cromwell Vicar General and,
281over the next five years, the honors increased - Lord Privy Seal, titled
282Baron Cromwell of Oakham, Knight of the Garter and Dean of Wells, and finally
283Lord Great Chancellor and ennoblement as Earl of Essex.&nbsp; The last
284was Cromwell's greatest ambition and long before justified by his superior
285service to the crown.&nbsp; During the accumulation of these honors, however,
286Cromwell began to recognize the flaws in his success.
287<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; First, he had accompanied Anne Boleyn on her rise
288to power; yet, in 1536, he helped engineer her disgrace and execution on
289charges of adultery, incest, and witchcraft.&nbsp; Why?&nbsp; Cromwell
290recognized Henry's dissatisfaction with the marriage - after several years,
291Anne's sharp tongue had offended many and, even worse, she had not produced
292a male heir.&nbsp; Furthermore, Henry had become infatuated with Anne's
293lady-in-waiting, Mistress Jane Seymour.&nbsp; Tiring of his wife, he wanted
294to be rid of her.&nbsp; Divorce was only briefly considered before being
295pushed aside.&nbsp; As he had with Katharine of Aragon, Henry became convinced
296his marriage was invalid, only this time because of adultery, and he retained
297his absolute conviction in her guilt even as he truly believed his and
298Katharine's marriage was invalid.&nbsp; To rid himself of Anne, he turned
299to the ever-ready Cromwell.&nbsp; Soon enough, Anne was on trial with her
300brother and two male servants.&nbsp; They were all executed, despite spirited
301defenses and the widely-held belief that it was judicial murder.
302<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Cromwell betrayed his former patron because she no
303longer held the king's favor.&nbsp; In the rough world of Tudor politics,
304friendships were lost in the struggle for prestige and survival.&nbsp;
305And now Cromwell turned to Mistress Jane Seymour and her relatively obscure
306family for support.&nbsp; The Seymours, however, never warmed to Cromwell
307as had the Boleyns, largely because they didn't trust him or his influence
308over the king.&nbsp; Cromwell was careful to press Jane's cause to the
309king though Henry needed little urging.&nbsp; Just days after Anne Boleyn's
310execution, Jane Seymour became his third wife, dying eighteen months later
311after delivering the longed-for son, Prince Edward.&nbsp; Cromwell busied
312himself with auctioning off church properties to various noblemen and further
313reforming the archaic machinery of Tudor government.&nbsp; In doing so,
314he continued to ignore Henry's council of noble peers.&nbsp; When the council
315did meet, Cromwell dominated the meetings and disregarded most suggestions.&nbsp;
316To his credit, he was right on most counts; the nobility was quite distanced
317from the changing nature of government.&nbsp; They were fiercely protective
318of their own 'inalienable' rights as landowners and peers and notoriously
319difficult when these rights were impugned (this conflict between the nobility
320and monarchy was centuries-old - simply remember the 13th century <i>Magna
321Carta</i>, when the nobles forced King John I to recognize their 'natural'
322rights.)
323<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; As discussed earlier, the nobility resented Cromwell's
324influence with the king and his pro-monarchy, anti-nobility policy.&nbsp;
325And while many of the nobles benefited from the sale of clerical lands,
326many others had relatives dedicated to religious service.&nbsp; Also, reverence
327for the church and its servants was as deeply-held as reverence for the
328monarchy.&nbsp; Henry's attacks upon the church struck many as unnatural
329and wrong; since they could not turn on the king, they turned on Cromwell
330and blamed him for every unpopular policy.&nbsp; Henry VIII, who relished
331his popularity, allowed his faithful servant to be impugned.&nbsp; Thus,
332Henry could meet with his nobles, listen to their complaints, and even
333agree with them since many were his dearest friends.&nbsp; The king remained
334popular while his chief minister became increasingly despised and isolated.&nbsp;
335It is worth noting that one of Cromwell's friends, Richard Moryson, argued
336that merit and not birth should be the only qualification for entry into
337the privy council.&nbsp; Moryson eventually became a member himself.
338<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; It is also important to note that years of listening
339to anti-Cromwell gossip eventually affected Henry.&nbsp; Even the king
340did not exist in a vacuum and, as his temper became increasingly erratic,
341he was easily swayed by inflamed opinion.&nbsp; Thus, Cromwell suffered
342from a lapse in Henry's temper and one which the king almost immediately
343regretted.&nbsp; Chief among Cromwell's enemies were the highest nobles
344in the land, once Wolsey's great enemies and led by the dukes of Suffolk
345and Norfolk.&nbsp; These men had pushed Wolsey from favor after years of
346effort and were determined to do the same to his prot&eacute;g&eacute;.&nbsp;
347The perfect opportunity arrived when Queen Jane died two weeks after childbirth,
348in October 1537.&nbsp; Henry VIII was genuinely bereaved at her death but
349almost immediately the search began for a new queen.&nbsp; After all, Jane
350had delivered a son but one male heir was not enough in the sixteenth century.&nbsp;
351Henry's council began to search for a new consort with the king's enthusiastic
352support.
353<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; For Cromwell, this was a chance to further extend
354his influence while thwarting the English nobility.&nbsp; Henry's second
355and third wives had been English noblewomen whose families directly profited
356from their rise to power.&nbsp; The influence of these families naturally
357troubled Cromwell.&nbsp; As their influence rose, his own suffered - so
358he was opposed to the idea of another English wife.&nbsp; Also, as an intelligent
359statesman, he recognized the diplomatic power of royal marriages.&nbsp;
360Henry's troublesome foreign policy could be soothed if he chose a foreign
361wife - a princess or duchess of one of the great European families.&nbsp;
362Kings were meant to marry other royalty and Cromwell immediately searched
363for possible candidates.
364<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; While searching, he was careful to avoid Catholic
365candidates.&nbsp; Cromwell's rise to power was directly connected to the
366fall of Catholicism in England and he wanted to keep England on the path
367of Protestantism.&nbsp; Therefore, he sought a Protestant ally for Henry
368VIII.&nbsp; Naturally, his gaze turned to the Protestant states of Germany,
369birthplace of the Lutheran revolution.&nbsp; Meanwhile, Henry VIII was
370concerned with more aesthetic matters, sending artists (most famously,
371Hans Holbein the Younger) to France and Milan to paint potential brides.&nbsp;
372Among those painted was Christina, duchess of Milan and niece of the Holy
373Roman Emperor; she famously remarked that she would be happy to marry Henry
374- if she had two heads!&nbsp; Henry also considered Marie de Guise, a widowed
375cousin of the French king.&nbsp; Marie, however, chose to marry Henry's
376nephew, James V of Scotland, thus creating a French-Scottish alliance along
377Henry's troublesome northern border.&nbsp; Their only surviving child is
378famous in history as the tragic Mary queen of Scots.
379<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Cromwell was well aware that if France and the Holy
380Roman Empire ended hostilities, as seemed likely, England would be left
381out in the diplomatic cold.&nbsp; He was quite happy when the French and
382Imperial marriage negotiations fell apart.&nbsp; But as the search wound
383on, Henry became increasingly desperate for a wife.&nbsp; No doubt he was
384lonely; also, his court needed a queen to be complete.&nbsp; A king was
385not meant to be a bachelor, as every European monarch knew.&nbsp; Finally,
386Cromwell found a Protestant ally with two available sisters - the duke
387of Cleves, whose lands were strategically located and wealthy.&nbsp; He
388had two sisters not yet wed called Anne and Amelia.&nbsp; As the eldest,
389Anne was chosen as the possible bride and Holbein immediately went to Cleves
390to paint her portrait.&nbsp; <a href="http://www.geocities.com/athens/forum/9194/cleves1.jpg">This
391painting</a> would become of paramount importance in the coming year.&nbsp;
392Henry was determined to have a beautiful wife and specifically asked his
393various ambassadors probing questions - does Marie de Guise have wide hips
394for childbearing? is Christina of Milan pock-marked? does Anne of Cleves
395play the lute?&nbsp; Holbein's famous portrait of Anne cannot be adequately
396judged in our time; after all, standards of beauty have changed.&nbsp;
397However, it is amusing to note that she - so maligned in her own time as
398the ugliest of Henry's wives - is the most attractive by twentieth-century
399standards.
400<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Holbein's portrait showed a perfectly attractive
401young woman - and, on that basis, Cromwell was able to secure the marriage
402alliance with a Protestant ally.&nbsp; Anne set sail for England, little
403realizing what lay ahead.&nbsp; The king, meanwhile, was ecstatic that
404after almost three years as a widower he would be a husband again, able
405to play one of his favorite roles.&nbsp; The entire country was thrilled
406at the news, in fact, and after Anne arrived, Cromwell finally secured
407his greatest ambition - an earldom.&nbsp; He was titled earl of Essex by
408Henry VIII on 18 April 1540 after the marriage treaty was finalized.
409<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; During this time, he also attempted to placate the
410nobility by redistributing lands to the great magnates, providing them
411with near-autonomous controls of great sections of land.&nbsp; For example,
412the duke of Suffolk traded East Anglian lands for lands in Lincolnshire
413- the duke of Norfolk already held lands in Anglia while Lincolnshire needed
414a strong leader.&nbsp; Earlier, Cromwell had attempted to befriend Henry's
415oldest child, the stubbornly Catholic Princess Mary.&nbsp; She rebuffed
416his attention, largely on religious grounds.
417<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Two years of marriage-brokering were often interrupted
418by rumors of rebellion.&nbsp; The Pilgrimage of Grace had made Henry more
419sensitive to popular sentiment.&nbsp; While Cromwell searched for a wife,
420rumors spread that the king planned new taxes.&nbsp; Also, the last remnants
421of the legitimate Plantagenet line - the Nevilles, Poles, and Courtenays
422- were suspected of encouraging rebellionn and Henry used this convenient
423excuse to order more executions.&nbsp; But popular unrest needed to be
424assuaged in some manner so Cromwell engineered the passing of the Six Articles
425at Parliament in April 1539.&nbsp; These articles attempted to stamp a
426more conservative gloss on the Henrician reformation, thus placating conservative
427European nobles - and the Catholic nations in Europe, now forced to concede
428Henry was not so great a heretic after all.&nbsp; It was a supreme example
429of Cromwell's talent for diffusing domestic tension.&nbsp; In effect, it
430was all talk and no action; it didn't alter the course of the reformation
431one bit.
432<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Finally, on 6 October 1539, the marriage treaty with
433Cleves was finalized just two months after Holbein delivered his portrait.&nbsp;
434Princess Anne, once betrothed to the duke of Lorraine, was now destined
435to be queen of England.&nbsp; It was the fulfillment of Cromwell's domestic
436and foreign policies.&nbsp; On 11 December, Anne was at Calais waiting
437for a favorable wind to carry her to Dover.&nbsp; She was there for almost
438two weeks while Henry waited at Greenwich.&nbsp; Finally, on 27 December
439she landed at Deal and then traveled to Dover and Canterbury before arriving
440at Rochester on 1 January 1540.&nbsp; Henry, desperate to see his bride
441in person, rushed in disguise to meet her 'to thus nourish love', he told
442Cromwell.&nbsp; Their comical first meeting is described at the <a href="../primary.html">Primary
443Sources</a> section.
444<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The meeting was an unmitigated disaster and the beginning
445of Cromwell's end.&nbsp; The New Year gifts Henry had brought for Anne
446were delivered the next day by a courier with a brief note of welcome.&nbsp;
447'I am ashamed that men have so praised her as they have done, and I like
448her not', the king said ominously; he told Cromwell that Anne was 'nothing
449so well as she was spoken of' and, if he had known the truth of her appearance,
450she would never have come to England.&nbsp; The next day, his betrothed
451arrived in Greenwich and the marriage, scheduled for that day, was delayed
452for two days while Henry sought escape.&nbsp; But there was none to be
453had - the Holy Roman Emperor was in Paris meeting with the French king
454and Henry, locked out by those two great powers, could not risk offending
455the German princes who approved the union with Anne.&nbsp; They were, after
456all, his only allies at the moment.&nbsp; So Anne was not sent back and
457Henry moaned that he must 'put my neck in the yoke'.&nbsp; He wrote to
458Cromwell, 'My lord, if it were not to satisfy the world and my realm, I
459would not do that I must do this day for none earthly thing'.
460<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Poor Anne of Cleves - barely able to speak English,
461in a foreign land, and despised by her intended husband!&nbsp; The confused
462woman was led to a private marriage ceremony at Greenwich and, then, to
463her equally humiliating marriage-bed.&nbsp; The union was not consummated,
464a subject upon which Henry never wavered.&nbsp; He spoke openly of how
465disgusted he was by Anne's appearance; 'struck to the heart' by distaste,
466he 'left her as good a maid as he found her'.&nbsp; They lay together for
467the entire length of their marriage but were never physically intimate.&nbsp;
468After a few months had passed, the French-Imperial alliance showed signs
469of cooling and Henry's natural boldness had returned.&nbsp; He wanted out
470of this fourth marriage and told Cromwell to arrange it.
471<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; What were Cromwell's options?&nbsp; There were two
472ways to nullify the marriage (in essence, arrange a divorce) - Henry had
473not consented to the marriage (this was proved by his failure to consummate
474it) and Anne had not consented to the marriage (this was proved by Anne's
475precontract to the duke of Lorraine.)&nbsp; Henry had long been concerned
476with the latter problem - but had been assured that the contract was completely
477repudiated.&nbsp; Still, the day before his marriage to Anne, he called
478the Clevian ambassadors to him and raised the issue.&nbsp; They were astonished,
479and rightly so, and offered to remain as prisoners in England until the
480formal repudiation papers were delivered from Cleves.&nbsp; Meanwhile,
481Thomas Cranmer told the king that Anne could simply swear that the betrothal
482had been repudiated - no official documents were necessary.&nbsp; His friend
483Cromwell 'travailed on him [Henry] to pass the matter over'; he hoped that
484once Henry was married to Anne, the king would resign himself to the marriage.
485<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; But instead Henry turned to the precontract when
486his distaste could not be overcome.&nbsp; On 9 July, Parliament declared
487the marriage null and void and Anne, surprising Henry and the court, was
488content to be called 'sister' and receive a handsome income and household
489in England.&nbsp; She had no desire to return to Cleves, where she would
490remain under her brother's thumb and perhaps married again.&nbsp; It is
491also possible she found Henry as unattractive as he found her.&nbsp; Henry
492was so pleased with this unexpected docility that he gave her status second
493only to his daughters, Princesses Mary and Elizabeth, both of whom came
494to befriend Anne.&nbsp; Anne's letter to Henry, in which she accepts the
495dissolution of their marriage, can be read at '<a href="../letters.html">Letters
496of the Six Wives of Henry VIII</a>'.
497<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; However, the time had come to search for a convenient
498scapegoat - the person responsible for the disastrous union.&nbsp; Henry
499railed against his ambassadors who had so misled him with descriptions
500of her beauty - though, in truth, the ambassador's descriptions had been
501honest.&nbsp; It was soon alleged that Cromwell had kept them from the
502king, for fear of discouraging the union.&nbsp; Now, Cromwell was arrested
503on 10 June 1540, at 3pm on a Saturday, while at a Privy Council meeting.&nbsp;
504This was a full month before the marriage was nullified.&nbsp; Henry and
505Cromwell's enemies were in the midst of finding scapegoats for the marriage,
506while not yet assured of its outcome.&nbsp; Henry, in a fit of temper and
507pique, complained bitterly that his minister had betrayed him while trying
508to further his own influence; the nobility were only too happy to encourage
509such thoughts.&nbsp; They urged Henry to arrest Cromwell and teach the
510upstart his final lesson - namely, that it does not pay to mislead a king.
511<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; So the captain of the guard arrived at the council
512chamber and arrested Cromwell, while a table of his enemies looked on.&nbsp;
513The moment the guard entered the room, Cromwell recognized the danger -
514and threw his hat upon the table in rage.&nbsp; Norfolk and Southampton
515stripped his decorations from his robe of state and Cromwell was then escorted
516to a barge - and, then, the Tower of London.&nbsp; The events which follow
517are far from clear - Cromwell's fall and execution are among the most mysterious
518events of Henry VIII's reign and cannot be easily understood.&nbsp; I have
519yet to read a history which offers an adequate explanation.&nbsp; In truth,
520Henry became increasingly mercurial and tempermental in his later years,
521and Cromwell was just one of many victims of the king's ever-changing whims.
522<p><font size=+1>&nbsp;</font> First, if Cromwell fell from favor because
523of the Cleves marriage, as most believe, why did Henry title him earl of
524Essex in April 1540 - months after the marriage had been finalized and
525while negotiations for divorce were underway?&nbsp; Second, if Cromwell
526was executed because his government policies angered the king, as has been
527alleged, why did Henry give his voluntary approval to all of Cromwell's
528legislation?&nbsp; Third, is his enemies were in the ascendancy, why had
529Henry only recently shown the duke of Norfolk (Cromwell's great enemy)
530open favor?&nbsp; After all, Norfolk had just been sent abroad on diplomatic
531work - away from the king.
532<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; What are we left with?&nbsp; The charges eventually
533listed in Cromwell's attainder <i>did not</i> list the above - Cromwell
534was not accused of misleading Henry on matters of policy, he was not held
535responsible for the disastrous marriage, and he was not charged with leading
536England into an unwanted Lutheran alliance.&nbsp; Instead, he was charged
537with selling export licenses illegally, granting passports and commissions
538without royal knowledge, freeing people suspected of treason and - of course
539- that he, base-born and ignoble, had usuurped and deliberately misused
540royal power.&nbsp; Most significantly, however, he was charged with heresy
541- this charge was the bulk of his attaindder and apparently swayed Henry
542decisively.&nbsp; Norfolk, allied with the Catholic bishops Cromwell had
543forced from power, engineered this charge.&nbsp; Cromwell, they charged,
544had encouraged and spread heretical literature, allowed heretics to preach,
545released them from prison, and allied himself against their enemies.&nbsp;
546Significantly, it was reported that in March 1539 Cromwell said that, even
547if Henry turned from Protestantism, 'yet I would not turn, and if the king
548did turn, and all his people, I would fight in this field in mine own person,
549with my sword in my hand <i>against him</i> and all other'.&nbsp; That
550was treason.
551<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; Shortly after his arrest, incriminating letters to
552Lutherans were found in Cromwell's home, placed there by agents of the
553duke of Norfolk; they were so inflammatory that the king was outraged.&nbsp;
554Cromwell's name, Henry swore, would be abolished forever.&nbsp; Cromwell
555wrote two desperate letters from the Tower; the one that survives is in
556tatters.&nbsp; He assured his monarch that he was a good, loyal servant
557and a faithful Christian.&nbsp; But Henry, surrounded by Cromwell's enemies
558and - more significantly - newly infatuated with Norfolk's niece, Catherine
559Howard, would hear nothing.&nbsp; Furthermore, Norfolk was shrewd enough
560to create a Lutheran conspiracy; three popular reformers, Robert Barnes,
561Thomas Garret, and William Jerome, were executed just days after Cromwell.&nbsp;
562None of the men were allowed an open trial.&nbsp; That would allow the
563public opportunity for them to dispute the false charges.&nbsp; Instead,
564they were condemned by Act of Attainder, a parliamentary tool which dispensed
565with justice in favor of speed.
566<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; The executed men were also neighbors of Cromwell,
567which was their only link to the earl.&nbsp; And they were as innocent
568as Cromwell of the charges against them - as evidenced by the confusion
569of contemporary chroniclers.&nbsp; Edward Hall, one of the great chroniclers
570of Tudor England, could find no real evidence against them although he
571'searched to know the truth'.
572<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; So Cromwell was executed privately on Tower Green
573on 28 July 1540, still protesting his innocence.&nbsp; He died with dignity
574- but the whole sordid affair of his deatth would not rest.&nbsp; For the
575volatile Henry VIII was soon despairing of his loss, just a few months
576after he allowed the execution.&nbsp; He raged at his council, accusing
577them of lying and deliberately destroying his 'most faithful servant'.&nbsp;
578Cromwell's destruction had been engineered on 'light pretexts' and against
579the king's wishes.&nbsp; In truth, Henry was a victim as well - of a determined
580group of nobles and clerics, led by Norfolk, who hated Cromwell and carried
581the king along on their path of destruction.&nbsp; Events were rapid and
582deliberately confused.&nbsp; By the time Henry realized what had happened,
583it was too late.&nbsp; He could only bemoan his loss, while never understanding
584exactly why it happened.
585<p>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; This was no comfort to Thomas Cromwell, however;
586after a lifetime of dedicated service, he met his end by execution and
587all of Henry's regrets could not bring him back to life.
588<center>
589<hr WIDTH="100%">
590<br><font size=-1><a href="../citizens.html">to
591Tudor Citizens</a></font>
592<br><font size=-1><a href="http://englishhistory.net/tudor.html">to Tudor
593England</a></font>
594<p><b><font size=-1>Want to learn more about Cromwell?</font></b>
595<br><font size=-1>Try these books (used as sources for my article) -</font>
596<br><font size=-1>The Cardinal and the Secretary: Thomas Wolsey and Thomas
597Cromwell</font>
598<br><font size=-1>by Neville Williams.</font>
599<br><font size=-1>Policy and Police: the enforcement of the Reformation
600in the Age of Thomas Cromwell</font>
601<br><font size=-1>by G. R. Elton.</font>
602<br><font size=-1>Reform and Renewal: Thomas Cromwell and the Common Weal</font>
603<br><font size=-1>by G. R. Elton.</font>
604<br><font size=-1>Thomas Cromwell and the English Reformation</font>
605<br><font size=-1>by A. G. Dickens.</font>
606<br><font size=-1>Thomas Cromwell: Tudor Minister</font>
607<br><font size=-1>by B. W. Beckingsale.</font></center>
608
609</body>
610</html>
611<!-- text below generated by server. PLEASE REMOVE --><!-- Counter/Statistics data collection code --><script language="JavaScript" src="http://hostingprod.com/js_source/geov2.js"></script><script language="javascript">geovisit();</script><noscript><img src="http://visit.webhosting.yahoo.com/visit.gif?us1108082581" alt="setstats" border="0" width="1" height="1"></noscript>
612<IMG SRC="http://geo.yahoo.com/serv?s=76001524&t=1108082581" ALT=1 WIDTH=1 HEIGHT=1>
Note: See TracBrowser for help on using the repository browser.